When it comes to feeding your furry friend, few brands have revolutionized the pet food industry quite like The Honest Kitchen. Founded in 2002 by Lucy Postins, this company started with a simple yet revolutionary idea – making dog food that’s literally good enough for humans to eat. As someone who’s analyzed countless dog food brands, I can tell you that The Honest Kitchen stands apart in several meaningful ways.
The Honest Kitchen’s Origin Story
The brand began in Lucy Postins’ kitchen when her Rhodesian Ridgeback, Mosi, was struggling with chronic ear infections and skin problems. Frustrated with conventional pet food options, she started preparing human-grade meals at home. The remarkable improvement in Mosi’s health inspired what would become an industry-changing company.
What began as homemade dehydrated recipes has evolved into a comprehensive line of products, all maintaining the founding principle that our pets deserve food made to human consumption standards. This wasn’t just a marketing angle – Postins fought for it, even winning a landmark legal battle in 2007 that established their right to use “human-grade” labeling.
What Makes The Honest Kitchen Different?
The Honest Kitchen’s primary distinction is their human-grade certification. They became the first pet food company to receive FDA recognition for meeting human food production standards in 2004. This means their ingredients, facilities, and manufacturing processes all meet regulations for human food production – a standard that goes far beyond typical pet food requirements.
Their production methods also set them apart. Rather than extruding kibble at high temperatures (which can destroy nutrients), they initially focused on gentle dehydration that preserves nutritional integrity. In 2019, they introduced Whole Food Clusters using a proprietary MadeHonest™ process that combines slow-roasting and dehydration without conventional extrusion.
As a Public Benefit Corporation since 2021, the company has formalized its commitment to transparency, ethical sourcing, and environmental sustainability – values that have guided the brand since its inception.
Product Lines and Options
Dehydrated Recipes
The original product line features minimally processed, dehydrated whole foods that you rehydrate with warm water. A 10lb box typically makes about 40lbs of fresh food when rehydrated. These recipes come in various protein options including chicken, turkey, beef, and fish, with both grain-inclusive and grain-free varieties.
I’ve always appreciated how these dehydrated recipes let you actually see the real ingredients – you can identify diced carrots, peas, and meat pieces, creating a visual reassurance of quality that’s rare in pet food.
Whole Food Clusters
For those seeking convenience without sacrificing quality, their Whole Food Clusters offer a ready-to-serve dry food alternative. Introduced in 2019, these cold-pressed clusters maintain higher nutritional integrity than traditional kibble. They’re made in The Honest Kitchen’s human-grade facility in Kansas, which spans 100,000 square feet and opened in 2021.
Clusters come in varieties like Chicken, Beef, Turkey, and Fish, with options for puppies, adults, and seniors. Prices start around $42.99 for a 4.5lb bag, reflecting the premium ingredients and production methods.
Additional Products
The Honest Kitchen has expanded beyond their core offerings to include:
- Wet food in bone broth-based recipes
- Toppers and mix-ins to enhance regular meals
- Treats and supplements maintaining their human-grade standards
Nutritional Philosophy
The brand’s approach to nutrition centers on whole food ingredients without corn, wheat, soy, by-products, or artificial preservatives. They incorporate functional ingredients like organic kelp (for iodine) and salmon oil (for essential fatty acids).
Protein levels are generally high – for example, their Limited Ingredient Chicken recipe contains 26% protein, aligning with more ancestral dietary patterns for dogs. In 2022, they conducted extensive AAFCO feeding trials that went beyond standard protocols by including echocardiograms, comprehensive bloodwork, and six months of health monitoring.
Not sure about The Honest Kitchen? You might want to check out our Spot and Tango review for another human-grade option with a different approach.
Customer Experiences
The feedback from pet parents using The Honest Kitchen has been largely positive, with many reporting significant health improvements. Common benefits mentioned include resolved allergies, improved coat quality, and better digestion. Many owners note that even picky eaters seem to enjoy the food when properly rehydrated.
However, the brand isn’t without criticisms. The most common concerns involve:
- Price point – costing 3-4 times more than conventional kibble
- Texture issues with the clusters (some report excessive crumbling)
- Transition challenges for some dogs adjusting to the new textures
Some customers have also raised questions about the inclusion of potatoes and legumes in newer formulations, given ongoing discussions about diet-related dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM), though the company’s AAFCO trials provide some reassurance on nutritional adequacy.
What Kind of Dogs Is This Food Suitable For?
The Honest Kitchen offers formulations suitable for dogs across all life stages and needs, but it particularly shines for certain groups:
Dogs with sensitivities or allergies often do exceptionally well on The Honest Kitchen’s Limited Ingredient diets. The minimal processing and high-quality protein sources can help reduce inflammatory responses that trigger skin issues and digestive problems. I’ve personally seen dramatic improvements in dogs with chronic itching after switching to these recipes.
Senior dogs benefit from the high digestibility and bioavailability of nutrients in gently processed foods. The warm, soft texture of rehydrated recipes is easier on aging teeth and gums, while providing quality protein to maintain muscle mass.
Active, performance dogs appreciate the clean protein sources and lack of fillers, which provide sustained energy without the carbohydrate overload found in many conventional foods.
Puppies can start on their specific puppy formulations, which provide the balanced nutrition needed for proper development. The Whole Food Clusters puppy formula is particularly convenient for growing dogs.
For dogs needing weight management, the portion control enabled by rehydrating precise amounts of their dehydrated recipes allows for careful calorie monitoring without sacrificing nutrition.
The main limitation is for budget-conscious owners of large or multiple dogs, as the cost can become prohibitive at larger serving sizes.
Is This Dog Food Good? My Professional Assessment
As a dog nutrition specialist, I consider The Honest Kitchen to be among the highest quality commercial dog foods available on the market today. Their human-grade certification isn’t just marketing – it represents a fundamentally higher standard of ingredients, processing, and safety protocols.
The minimally processed nature of their products preserves more nutrients than conventional extrusion, and their avoidance of artificial preservatives, colors, and flavors eliminates many potential irritants. Their AAFCO feeding trials provide scientific validation that their foods support long-term health.
That said, The Honest Kitchen isn’t the perfect choice for everyone. The significant price premium makes it inaccessible for many pet owners, especially those with larger dogs. Some of their grain-free formulations include ingredients like legumes that have come under scrutiny in DCM discussions, though their feeding trials and transparent formulation provide some reassurance.
What impresses me most is their consistent commitment to quality over their 20+ year history. Unlike many brands that start with premium ingredients but quietly reformulate after being acquired by larger corporations, The Honest Kitchen has maintained their standards while expanding their product line.
In my professional opinion, for those who can afford it, The Honest Kitchen represents one of the best commercial options available – especially for dogs with health sensitivities or owners prioritizing minimal processing.
Find Your Dog’s Perfect Food Match
Every dog has unique nutritional needs based on age, size, breed, activity level, and health conditions. While The Honest Kitchen might be ideal for some dogs, others may benefit from different formulations or brands.
That’s why we’ve created a quick, personalized questionnaire to help match your specific dog with their ideal food. In less than a minute, you can receive completely free recommendations for the three best dog food brands tailored specifically to your dog’s unique requirements.
No more guesswork or endless label reading – just science-based recommendations for your specific pup. Get your personalized dog food matches via this link.
