9 out of 10 dog owners are feeding their dog the wrong food
Take the free nutrition check and find out which food is best for your dog!
Shelter manager, certified canine nutritionist, and lifelong dog lover
• Real lamb leads the ingredient list, backed by lamb meal and fish meal for concentrated protein, delivering 28.9% protein on dry matter basis for healthy puppy growth.
• Grain-inclusive formula uses oatmeal, brown rice, and barley as primary carbohydrates, positioning it favorably amid ongoing FDA investigations into grain-free diets and DCM concerns.
• Chicken fat inclusion creates confusion despite “no chicken” packaging, potentially problematic for puppies with true poultry allergies but generally well-tolerated by most dogs.
• LifeSource Bits cause selective eating in some puppies, with many dogs picking around the different-shaped kibble pieces, making mealtimes frustrating for owners.
• Mid-premium pricing at $3 per pound delivers solid ingredient quality and nutrition that satisfies most puppy owners, though significantly more expensive than mainstream alternatives.
Deboned lamb takes the top spot on the ingredient list, which is exactly what you want to see in a puppy food. Real, whole meat as the first ingredient means your pup is getting quality animal protein right from the start. Following that, you’ll find menhaden fish meal and lamb meal—both concentrated protein sources that pack more nutritional punch per ounce than fresh meat because they’ve had the moisture removed.
What I find particularly valuable here is the combination of fresh lamb and lamb meal. Fresh meat contributes flavor and palatability, while the meal provides dense, bioavailable protein that supports muscle development in growing puppies. The menhaden fish meal adds omega-3 fatty acids, particularly DHA, which plays a role in brain and eye development during those critical early months.
Here’s where things get a bit complicated: the packaging prominently displays “no chicken” messaging, yet chicken fat appears in the ingredient list. For most puppies, this isn’t an issue—chicken fat is actually an excellent source of omega-6 fatty acids and energy. However, if your puppy has a genuine poultry allergy, this could be problematic. The fat itself contains minimal protein, which is typically what triggers allergic reactions, but it’s worth noting if you’re specifically avoiding all chicken-derived ingredients.
The formula relies on oatmeal, brown rice, and barley as its primary carbohydrate sources. These are wholesome, digestible grains that provide steady energy without the blood sugar spikes you might see with simpler carbohydrates. Oatmeal in particular offers soluble fiber that can support digestive health—many owners report their puppies have firm, well-formed stools on this food.
You’ll also notice pea starch, peas, and pea protein scattered throughout the ingredient list. While these aren’t inherently problematic, they do raise questions in light of the FDA’s ongoing investigation into potential links between legume-heavy diets and dilated cardiomyopathy in dogs. The good news? This formula is grain-inclusive, which means it doesn’t rely heavily on legumes the way many grain-free foods do. The grains provide the bulk of the carbohydrates here, with legumes playing a supporting role.
Dried tomato pomace, flaxseed, and pea fiber contribute additional fiber, supporting digestive transit and providing some phytonutrients. These aren’t filler ingredients—they serve functional purposes in the formula.
Blue Buffalo’s proprietary LifeSource Bits are those darker, differently shaped kibble pieces you’ll see mixed into every bag. These are cold-formed rather than extruded, which theoretically helps preserve heat-sensitive vitamins and antioxidants. The bits contain a concentrated blend of antioxidants, vitamins, and minerals, including ingredients like blueberries, cranberries, and kelp.
In practice, some puppies love these bits, while others pick around them. Multiple customer reviews mention puppies eating only the regular kibble and leaving the LifeSource Bits in the bowl. If your pup turns out to be one of these selective eaters, you might find yourself encouraging them to finish their meal or mixing everything together with a bit of warm water to make sorting impossible.
| Price per pound | $2.00 – $3.00 |
| Primary protein | Deboned lamb |
| By-products | None |
| AAFCO compliance | Yes (nutritional profile) |
| Formula options | Lamb & Oatmeal Puppy only |
| Availability | Target, Walmart, pet specialty stores |
On an as-fed basis, this formula delivers 26% crude protein and 16% crude fat. When you convert those numbers to a dry matter basis—which removes moisture from the equation and gives you a true comparison point—you’re looking at approximately 28.9% protein and 17.8% fat.
These levels comfortably exceed AAFCO’s minimum requirements for puppy growth, which call for at least 22.5% protein and 8.5% fat on a dry matter basis. The protein content supports the rapid muscle development puppies undergo, while the fat provides concentrated calories and essential fatty acids for brain development, healthy skin, and a shiny coat.
What I appreciate about these ratios is that they strike a moderate balance. You’re not seeing the ultra-high protein levels some premium brands offer, but you’re well above entry-level puppy foods. For most puppies—whether small, medium, or large breed—these levels support healthy growth without pushing too hard on developing systems.
Calcium and phosphorus deserve special attention in puppy foods because improper ratios can affect skeletal development, particularly in large-breed puppies. This formula provides 1.2% calcium and 1% phosphorus on an as-fed basis, which translates to approximately 1.33% calcium and 1.11% phosphorus on a dry matter basis.
These levels meet AAFCO minimums and fall within the recommended ranges. The calcium-to-phosphorus ratio sits at roughly 1.2:1, which is appropriate for growing dogs. Large-breed puppy owners sometimes worry about calcium levels, but these numbers are controlled enough to support healthy bone growth without overdoing it.
The formula guarantees at least 1% omega-3 fatty acids and 2.25% omega-6 fatty acids. More specifically, it provides a minimum of 0.10% DHA and 0.04% ARA—both particularly important for puppies.
DHA (docosahexaenoic acid) supports brain and eye development during those critical first months of life. The fish meal and fish oil in this formula are the primary sources. While 0.10% isn’t the highest level you’ll find in puppy foods, it represents a meaningful inclusion that goes beyond basic requirements. Many puppy owners notice their dogs seem alert and quick to learn on foods with adequate DHA levels.
Here’s where we run into some missing data. Without a published ash content, we can only estimate the carbohydrate level using the nitrogen-free extract calculation. Based on the guaranteed analysis, carbohydrates likely make up around 43-44% of the formula on an as-fed basis.
This positions the food as carb-rich with moderate protein and fat—a common profile for grain-inclusive puppy foods. The carbohydrates provide affordable calories and help keep the kibble structure intact, but they’re not the cheap fillers you might find in grocery-store brands. The whole grains used here offer nutritional value beyond just energy.
Blue Buffalo as a brand has experienced several recalls over the past 15 years, though none have specifically involved this Lamb & Oatmeal Puppy formula. The most recent recall occurred in February 2017, when certain canned dog foods were pulled due to potential metal contamination from a supplier issue. Earlier recalls in 2016 involved mold in a Fish & Sweet Potato recipe, and 2015 saw recalls for some treats containing propylene glycol.
Going further back, a 2010 recall involved excess vitamin D in certain formulas, and the 2007 melamine contamination crisis—which affected dozens of brands—included some Blue Buffalo products. As of 2025, there are no active FDA recalls for any Blue Buffalo products, including this one.
What matters more than a brand’s recall history is how they respond when issues arise. Blue Buffalo has generally acted quickly to remove affected products and communicate with customers. However, the frequency of past recalls does raise questions about supplier oversight and quality control consistency.
Blue Buffalo states they conduct in-house testing and work with ingredient suppliers to ensure quality, but they don’t publicly share third-party testing results or detailed quality certifications. You won’t find published heavy metal analyses, pathogen testing results, or independent audit reports readily available to consumers.
This lack of transparency is increasingly noticeable as some newer brands have started publishing detailed testing data online. While the absence of published results doesn’t necessarily mean the food is unsafe—it meets regulatory requirements and hasn’t shown contamination issues recently—it does mean you’re taking more on faith than you would with brands that share comprehensive testing information.
The formula is manufactured in the United States, and Blue Buffalo sources ingredients from the US, Canada, New Zealand, and Europe depending on the specific component. The company uses both their own facilities and third-party co-packers, though specific manufacturing locations for individual products aren’t publicly disclosed.
Each bag includes batch codes that allow you to trace production dates, which becomes important if a recall ever affects products from a specific facility or time period. The company provides customer service contact information if you want to inquire about a specific batch.
Blue Buffalo was acquired by General Mills in 2018 for approximately $8 billion, marking a major move by the food giant into the pet food market. Before that acquisition, Blue Buffalo had built a reputation as a “natural” pet food brand emphasizing whole ingredients and no by-products.
The General Mills ownership brings both advantages and considerations. On one hand, you have massive resources, established quality systems, and economies of scale. On the other, some consumers worry about corporate consolidation in pet food and whether the original brand values remain intact post-acquisition. In practice, the formulas appear to have remained consistent since the ownership change.
In 2014-2015, Purina filed a lawsuit against Blue Buffalo alleging false advertising regarding the company’s “no by-products” claims. The lawsuit revealed that some Blue Buffalo foods had indeed contained poultry by-product meal due to what the company called “supplier errors.” Blue Buffalo ultimately settled for $32 million and admitted the issue.
This matters because it speaks to transparency and quality control. The company has since tightened supplier oversight and continues to emphasize their no-by-product positioning. Current ingredient lists, including this Lamb & Oatmeal Puppy formula, don’t show by-product meals. Still, the incident left some consumers skeptical about marketing claims versus actual ingredients.
Blue Buffalo provides detailed ingredient lists and guaranteed analyses on their website and packaging. They list their customer service contact information prominently. What you won’t find easily is detailed information about their nutritionists’ credentials, specific manufacturing facility locations, or comprehensive quality testing results.
The WSAVA (World Small Animal Veterinary Association) recommends pet food companies employ qualified nutritionists with advanced degrees or board certification and make this information available to consumers. Blue Buffalo mentions working with veterinary and nutrition professionals but doesn’t publish specific credentials or staff backgrounds publicly.
Here’s the straightforward truth: there are no peer-reviewed studies specifically examining Blue Buffalo Lamb & Oatmeal Puppy’s effects on canine health. This isn’t unusual—most commercial dog foods haven’t been subjected to independent clinical trials. The absence of published research doesn’t mean the food is problematic; it simply means we’re relying on ingredient analysis, nutritional calculations, and consumer experiences rather than controlled scientific studies.
The formula meets AAFCO standards for puppy growth based on nutritional profiles, meaning it contains adequate levels of all essential nutrients as determined by feeding trial data and research on canine nutritional requirements. However, AAFCO compliance is a baseline, not a gold standard of excellence.
The FDA’s investigation into potential links between certain diets and dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) in dogs has made grain-inclusive formulas like this one more appealing to some owners. While the investigation remains ongoing and hasn’t established definitive causation, many veterinarians have become cautious about grain-free diets heavy in legumes.
This Blue Buffalo formula includes grains as primary carbohydrates, with legumes playing a smaller role. From a DCM-risk perspective, this positions it more favorably than grain-free alternatives, though we still don’t have complete answers about what dietary factors might contribute to the condition.
Lamb often gets positioned as a “novel” protein suitable for dogs with food sensitivities. In practice, whether lamb is truly novel depends on what your dog has eaten before. If your puppy has been exposed to chicken, beef, and turkey but never lamb, then yes, it’s novel for them. The digestibility of lamb protein is well-established, and many dogs with sensitive stomachs tolerate it well.
The combination of lamb with whole grains like oatmeal creates a formula that tends to be gentle on digestive systems. Multiple customer reviews mention improvements in stool quality and reductions in digestive upset after switching to this food.
Across Target, Walmart, and Blue Buffalo’s own website, this formula maintains an average rating around 4.5 out of 5 stars, with approximately 78% of reviews giving it five stars. The most consistent praise centers on palatability—owners frequently mention their puppies eagerly eating meals and showing enthusiasm at feeding time.
Coat quality improvements come up repeatedly. Owners notice their puppies developing shiny, soft coats within a few weeks of starting the food. This makes sense given the omega fatty acid content and quality protein sources. Digestive health also receives frequent positive mentions, with many owners reporting firm stools and reduced gas compared to previous foods.
For puppies with chicken sensitivities—or at least suspected sensitivities—owners report seeing improvements in skin itching, ear redness, and digestive issues after switching to this lamb-based formula. Whether these improvements stem from removing chicken meal or simply from switching to a higher-quality food overall is difficult to determine, but the practical result is happier puppies and relieved owners.
The “no chicken” packaging creates significant confusion and frustration. Multiple reviews express disappointment upon discovering chicken fat in the ingredient list after purchasing based on the prominent “no chicken” marketing. While the packaging technically says “no chicken by-product meals,” the visual presentation suggests complete chicken absence to many consumers.
Kibble shape selectivity surprises many puppy owners. The LifeSource Bits have a different texture and shape than the regular kibble, and some puppies develop strong preferences. Reviews describe puppies eating only the triangular regular kibble while leaving the round LifeSource Bits, or vice versa. This can make mealtimes frustrating as you watch your pup carefully sort through their bowl.
Price concerns appear frequently, particularly from owners comparing per-pound costs to grocery store brands. At roughly $3 per pound for the 5-pound bag, this formula costs significantly more than Purina Puppy Chow or similar mainstream options. Whether the ingredient quality justifies the premium depends on your priorities and budget.
A smaller number of reviews mention digestive upset during transition, with puppies experiencing loose stools or diarrhea when switching to this food. This isn’t unique to Blue Buffalo—any food change can cause temporary digestive disruption—but it’s worth noting for the gradual transition period.
Reading through hundreds of reviews reveals some interesting patterns. Small-breed puppy owners seem particularly satisfied with the formula, possibly because the kibble size works well for tiny mouths. Large-breed puppy owners also report good results, though some wish for a large-breed-specific version with adjusted calcium levels. If you’re raising a large-breed puppy, you might want to check out our blue buffalo large breed dog food review for options specifically formulated for bigger dogs.
Picky eaters get mentioned frequently in positive reviews. Owners who’ve struggled with finicky puppies often report this formula finally gets consistent meal completion. The combination of real lamb, natural flavors, and the fatty acid content seems to create an appealing taste profile for many dogs.
As of 2025, you’ll typically find the 5-pound bag priced around $14.98 at major retailers, working out to approximately $3.00 per pound or $0.66 per 100 grams. The 30-pound bag usually runs around $60-65, dropping the per-pound cost to roughly $2.00-2.17. Larger bags offer better value if your puppy will consume them before they go stale.
When you calculate cost per 1,000 calories—a more meaningful comparison metric—this formula comes in around $5.36. That’s notably higher than mainstream brands like Purina Pro Plan (approximately $3.80 per 1,000 kcal) but comparable to other natural/premium brands like Nutro Natural Choice.
Purina Pro Plan Puppy Lamb & Rice offers similar protein and fat levels with a significantly lower price point. The trade-off? You get corn gluten meal and poultry by-product meal in the ingredient list, plus artificial colors. If those ingredients don’t concern you, Pro Plan delivers solid nutrition for less money.
Nutro Natural Choice Puppy Lamb & Brown Rice sits closer to Blue Buffalo in both price and ingredient philosophy. You’ll find comparable whole-food ingredients and similar nutritional profiles. The main differences come down to specific ingredient choices and whether you value Blue Buffalo’s LifeSource Bits concept.
At the higher end, brands like Orijen and Acana push protein levels well above 30% on a dry matter basis and command prices of $7-9 per 1,000 calories. Whether those ultra-premium formulas offer meaningful advantages for most puppies is debatable—many thrive on the moderate protein and fat levels Blue Buffalo provides.
Value depends entirely on what you’re comparing against and what matters to you. If you’re moving from a $1-per-pound grocery store brand, the jump to $3 per pound feels significant. The question becomes whether the whole grains, real lamb, absence of by-products, and added nutrients justify tripling your food costs.
For most puppy owners, I’d say this formula represents solid mid-premium value. You’re paying more than necessary if budget is your primary concern, but you’re getting quality ingredients and appropriate nutrition for that premium. The food delivers on its basic promises—puppies generally thrive on it, enjoy eating it, and develop well.
Where the value calculation becomes trickier is for owners specifically seeking a chicken-free formula. If that’s your primary motivation, you need to decide whether chicken fat—which contains minimal protein and rarely causes issues—disqualifies this option for you. True chicken-free formulas exist but often cost even more.
This formula works particularly well for healthy puppies of any breed size who need balanced nutrition without extreme protein levels. If your puppy has shown sensitivity to chicken meal or you simply want to avoid poultry-based kibbles, this lamb formula offers a solid alternative—just be aware of that chicken fat if true poultry allergies are a concern.
Puppies with mildly sensitive stomachs often do well on this food. The whole grains provide easily digestible carbohydrates, and the lamb protein tends to be gentle. Multiple owners report improvements in stool consistency and reduced digestive upset after switching. If you’ve been dealing with frequent loose stools or gas, this formula is worth considering during your next transition.
For owners who value the natural ingredient approach—no artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives, no by-product meals, no corn, wheat, or soy—this formula ticks those boxes while maintaining reasonable pricing compared to ultra-premium options. You get the ingredient quality you’re looking for without entering the $4-5 per pound territory.
If your puppy has a diagnosed poultry allergy confirmed by your veterinarian, the chicken fat in this formula requires careful consideration. While fat contains minimal protein (the typical allergen trigger), some severely allergic dogs react to even trace amounts of poultry-derived ingredients. In those cases, a truly poultry-free formula makes more sense.
Budget-conscious owners feeding large-breed puppies might find the ongoing costs challenging. A Great Dane puppy eating 6-8 cups daily will go through a 30-pound bag in less than two weeks, creating monthly food costs of $120-150 or more. At that consumption level, a less expensive formula that still meets AAFCO standards might be more sustainable for your household.
Puppies requiring veterinary therapeutic diets for specific medical conditions need formulas prescribed by their veterinarian. This is a maintenance formula for healthy growth, not a medical diet. If your puppy has been diagnosed with conditions requiring dietary management, follow your vet’s recommendations rather than choosing over-the-counter options.
If you’re dealing with a picky puppy who turns their nose up at most foods, this formula has a good track record of winning over finicky eaters. The real lamb, natural flavors, and fat content create an appealing taste profile. However, there’s that kibble shape selectivity issue to consider—some puppies love everything, while others pick out only certain pieces.
One practical approach: if you have a picky eater, consider buying the smallest bag first to test acceptance before committing to the more economical larger sizes. The 5-pound bag costs more per pound but prevents you from being stuck with 30 pounds of food your puppy refuses to eat.
Like any food change, switching to Blue Buffalo Lamb & Oatmeal Puppy requires a gradual transition over 7-10 days. Start by mixing about 25% new food with 75% old food for the first few days, then move to 50/50, then 75% new food, and finally 100% new food. This gradual approach helps your puppy’s digestive system adjust and reduces the likelihood of upset stomach or loose stools.
Some puppies transition easily with minimal digestive disruption, while others need the full 10-day period or even longer. Watch your puppy’s stool consistency and energy levels during the transition. If you notice significant digestive upset, slow down the transition process or consult your veterinarian.
The bags use standard polypropylene packaging with a resealable top. Once opened, store the bag in a cool, dry location away from direct sunlight. For maximum freshness, many owners transfer the kibble to an airtight storage container, though you should keep the bag itself with its batch codes in case of recalls.
Natural formulas without artificial preservatives can be more susceptible to fat oxidation over time. For the smaller bags, this rarely becomes an issue if you’re using the food within 4-6 weeks. With the 30-pound bag, make sure your puppy will consume it within 6-8 weeks of opening to ensure optimal freshness and nutrient preservation.
Blue Buffalo doesn’t publish detailed feeding guidelines on their website for this specific formula, which is frustrating. The bag itself includes a feeding chart based on your puppy’s current weight and expected adult weight. As a general principle, puppies need more calories per pound of body weight than adult dogs due to their rapid growth and high energy needs.
Start with the bag’s recommendations and adjust based on your puppy’s body condition. You should be able to feel their ribs easily without seeing them prominently, and they should have a visible waist when viewed from above. Puppies grow in spurts, so their appetite and needs will fluctuate—don’t be surprised if they’re ravenous one week and less interested the next.
Blue Buffalo mentions “responsible sourcing” in their marketing materials but doesn’t provide detailed sustainability reports or third-party certifications for environmental practices. You won’t find information about carbon footprint, water usage, or renewable energy in their manufacturing processes readily available to consumers.
The lamb comes from US, New Zealand, and Canadian sources depending on availability—regions with generally established animal agriculture practices. However, without specific farm partnerships or welfare certifications, it’s difficult to assess the actual conditions in which the animals are raised.
The polypropylene bags aren’t widely recyclable through curbside programs, though some communities with specialized plastic recycling facilities may accept them. This is standard across most dog food brands—truly recyclable or compostable packaging remains rare in the pet food industry due to the need for moisture barriers and product protection.
If packaging waste concerns you, buying larger bags reduces the packaging-to-food ratio. A 30-pound bag uses far less plastic per pound of food than six 5-pound bags. Some pet stores also offer bulk purchasing or bag recycling programs, though availability varies by location.
Blue Buffalo Life Protection Formula Lamb & Oatmeal Puppy delivers on its core promise: real lamb as the primary protein, wholesome grains for energy, and appropriate nutrition for growing puppies. The formula meets AAFCO standards comfortably, includes beneficial additions like DHA and omega fatty acids, and avoids the controversial ingredients some owners want to skip—no by-products, no artificial colors or flavors, no corn, wheat, or soy.
The practical reality is that most puppies thrive on this food. They eat it eagerly, develop shiny coats, maintain healthy energy levels, and produce well-formed stools. For many owners, those observable results matter more than parsing ingredient lists or worrying about whether the protein could be two percentage points higher.
What requires consideration is the chicken fat inclusion if you’re specifically avoiding all poultry ingredients, the potential for kibble shape selectivity with the LifeSource Bits, and the premium pricing compared to mainstream alternatives. These aren’t dealbreakers for most situations, but they’re factors worth weighing against your specific needs and budget.
If you’re looking for a middle-ground option—better ingredients than grocery store brands, appropriate nutrition for healthy growth, and reasonable pricing compared to ultra-premium formulas—this Blue Buffalo formula fits that niche well. It won’t be the cheapest option at the pet store, nor will it be the most expensive. It represents solid quality at a mid-premium price point, which is exactly what many puppy owners are seeking.
For comprehensive information about Blue Buffalo’s full product line and company practices, you might want to read our main Blue Buffalo dog food review covering their entire range of formulas.
The decision ultimately comes down to whether this formula’s strengths align with your priorities and whether the considerations matter in your specific situation. For healthy puppies needing balanced nutrition with quality ingredients, this lamb and oatmeal recipe offers a reliable choice that’s helped thousands of puppies grow into healthy adult dogs.
This is where the packaging creates confusion. The bag prominently displays “no chicken” messaging, but chicken fat does appear in the ingredient list. The packaging technically states “no chicken by-product meals,” but many customers miss this distinction. Chicken fat contains minimal protein and rarely triggers allergic reactions, but if your puppy has a severe poultry allergy, this ingredient could be problematic. For most dogs, chicken fat is actually a beneficial source of omega-6 fatty acids.
Your puppy is likely picking around the LifeSource Bits—those darker, differently shaped pieces mixed into the kibble. These bits have a different texture and taste than the regular triangular kibble pieces. Some puppies develop strong preferences and will eat only one type while leaving the other. You can try mixing everything together with a bit of warm water to make sorting impossible, or gradually reduce meal portions so your pup gets hungry enough to eat everything.
Yes, the calcium and phosphorus levels are appropriate for large breed puppies. The formula provides 1.2% calcium and 1% phosphorus with a ratio of approximately 1.2:1, which supports healthy skeletal development without overdoing calcium. However, if you’re raising a giant breed puppy (expected adult weight over 90 pounds), you might want to consult your veterinarian about whether a large-breed-specific formula would be more appropriate.
This depends entirely on your puppy’s size and age. A small breed puppy might make a 5-pound bag last 3-4 weeks, while a large breed puppy could finish it in a week. The 30-pound bag typically lasts 4-8 weeks for most puppies, depending on their size and growth stage. Remember that puppies eat more relative to their body weight than adult dogs, and their appetite will fluctuate during growth spurts.
Many owners report good results with sensitive stomach puppies on this formula. The whole grains like oatmeal and brown rice are easily digestible, and lamb protein tends to be gentle on digestive systems. Multiple reviews mention improvements in stool consistency and reduced gas after switching. However, always transition gradually over 7-10 days, and consult your veterinarian if your puppy has ongoing digestive issues.
At approximately $3 per pound, this formula costs significantly more than mainstream options like Purina Puppy Chow. Whether it’s worth the premium depends on your priorities. You’re paying for real lamb as the first ingredient, whole grains instead of corn and wheat, and no artificial colors or by-product meals. Many owners feel the ingredient quality and their puppy’s response justify the cost, while others find excellent results with less expensive alternatives.
Store the bag in a cool, dry location away from direct sunlight. Many owners transfer the kibble to an airtight storage container for maximum freshness, though you should keep the original bag with its batch codes in case of recalls. Natural formulas without artificial preservatives can be more susceptible to fat oxidation, so try to use opened bags within 6-8 weeks for optimal freshness.
Blue Buffalo has experienced several recalls over the past 15 years, though none specifically involved this Lamb & Oatmeal Puppy formula. The most recent recall was in 2017 for certain canned foods due to potential metal contamination. As of 2025, there are no active FDA recalls for any Blue Buffalo products. The company generally responds quickly when issues arise, but the frequency of past recalls does raise questions about quality control consistency.
Yes, you can add healthy toppers like plain cooked vegetables, a small amount of plain yogurt, or puppy-safe fruits in moderation. However, remember that treats and toppers should make up no more than 10% of your puppy’s daily calories to maintain nutritional balance. Avoid adding foods that are toxic to dogs like onions, grapes, or chocolate. If you’re mixing with another kibble, do so gradually to prevent digestive upset.
First, ensure you’re transitioning gradually from their previous food rather than switching abruptly. If your puppy consistently refuses the food after a proper transition period, you have a few options: try mixing with a small amount of warm water to enhance aroma, add a tiny bit of plain cooked chicken or bone broth, or consider that this particular formula might not suit your puppy’s taste preferences. Don’t let a puppy go more than 12-24 hours without eating—consult your veterinarian if meal refusal continues.
9 out of 10 dog owners are feeding their dog the wrong food.
Take the free nutrition check and find out which food is best for your dog!
2,847+ dog owners already did
