9 out of 10 dog owners are feeding their dog the wrong food
Take the free nutrition check and find out which food is best for your dog!
Shelter manager, certified canine nutritionist, and lifelong dog lover
• Exceptional value proposition – delivers 25-30% protein with functional ingredients like glucosamine and probiotics at roughly half the cost of premium competitors like Purina Pro Plan.
• Clean safety record with limited transparency – no major recalls in the past decade, but lacks published feeding trials, sourcing details, and third-party lab testing data.
• Strong palatability and digestive performance – 70% of user reviews highlight enthusiastic acceptance, with consistent reports of firmer stools and improved coat shine within weeks.
• Ideal for active dogs and budget-conscious multi-dog households – True Professional 30/20 formula costs $0.88 daily for large dogs versus $1.45 for comparable premium options.
• Limited specialization and variety – lacks veterinary diets, extensive flavor options, and small-breed formulas, making it unsuitable for dogs with severe allergies or complex health needs.
Nutrena started life in 1921 as Miller-McConnell Grain Company in Kansas City, Kansas, and became a registered brand that same year. In 1945, Cargill acquired Nutrena, folding it into one of the world’s largest private agribusiness corporations. Over the decades, Nutrena absorbed multiple feed mills and brands, expanding from livestock nutrition into companion animal feeds, including dog and cat food in the 1960s.
Today, Nutrena operates as a division of Cargill Animal Nutrition and positions itself as a research-driven, value-oriented brand for both production animals and pets. The company emphasizes “powering your best” with formulas developed by animal nutritionists, meeting or exceeding AAFCO standards, and using real animal protein as the first ingredient with no artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives. Core values center on reliability, affordability, and science-backed nutrition, targeting rural families, multi-dog households, and owners who want functional nutrition without premium-tier pricing.
Nutrena’s reputation is solid but quiet—it doesn’t command the household recognition of Purina or Blue Buffalo, and you won’t find it in most grocery stores. Instead, it thrives in feed stores, farm supply chains like Tractor Supply, and regional retailers. The brand benefits from Cargill’s financial stability and global supply network, but transparency on sourcing, audits, and quality control lags behind premium competitors. There have been no major recalls in the past decade, which speaks to consistent manufacturing standards, yet the lack of published feeding trials, third-party lab testing, or detailed ingredient traceability leaves some questions unanswered for owners who prioritize full transparency.
Nutrena’s formulas typically lead with chicken, chicken meal, lamb meal, beef, or salmon, depending on the recipe. Chicken and chicken meal dominate the Loyall Life and True lines, while the Advanced Solutions and grain-free options introduce salmon and lamb for dogs with sensitivities. Chicken meal is a concentrated protein source—moisture removed, higher protein per pound than fresh chicken—but the brand does not disclose whether it’s sourced from whole chickens or parts, nor does it specify suppliers or countries of origin.
Protein percentages range from 21% in maintenance formulas to 31% in puppy and performance lines, which is respectable for mid-range kibble. However, without published digestibility data or amino acid profiles, it’s hard to gauge how well your dog will actually absorb and use that protein. Premium brands often provide biological value scores or feeding trial results; Nutrena does not.
Most Nutrena recipes rely on brown rice, corn, and wheat as primary carbohydrate sources. The grain-free options swap these for sweet potato, peas, and lentils. Corn and wheat are affordable, digestible energy sources for many dogs, but they’re also common allergens and can cause issues for sensitive dogs. The brand markets its grain-inclusive formulas as balanced and digestible, and many user reviews back that up with reports of firm stools and steady energy.
The grain-free lines use legumes and potatoes, which have been linked to dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) in some studies, though the FDA has not conclusively tied specific ingredients or brands to the condition. Nutrena doesn’t address DCM concerns publicly, and the grain-free recipes don’t appear to be formulated with exotic proteins or particularly high legume loads compared to some competitors, but it’s worth noting if your dog has a heart condition or breed predisposition.
Fat content ranges from 12% in maintenance formulas to 20% in puppy and performance lines, with chicken fat and fish oil listed as primary sources. Chicken fat is palatable and energy-dense; fish oil provides omega-3 fatty acids (EPA and DHA) for skin, coat, joint, and cognitive health. Nutrena guarantees omega-6 and omega-3 levels on some labels, which is a plus, but exact ratios and sourcing details are not published.
Nutrena includes glucosamine and chondroitin sulfate for joint health, prebiotics and probiotics for digestion, and a proprietary ingredient called TruMune, described as a postbiotic for immune and mobility support. The inclusion of these functional ingredients is a selling point, especially in the Loyall Life Advanced Solutions and True Professional lines, but the brand does not disclose dosages or clinical evidence for efficacy. Many premium brands publish studies or dosage thresholds; Nutrena does not, so it’s unclear if these ingredients are present at therapeutic levels or just marketing dust.
Nutrena claims no artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives, which is good. Natural preservatives like mixed tocopherols (vitamin E) are standard and safe. The brand also adds a vitamin and mineral pack to meet AAFCO profiles, including taurine for heart health and a range of B vitamins, vitamin A, and vitamin E. No controversial additives like BHA, BHT, or ethoxyquin appear on ingredient lists.
Nutrena does not publish sourcing transparency—you won’t find country-of-origin details for chicken, grains, or supplements. There’s no traceability tool or supplier list, and no third-party certification for ingredient quality (like Non-GMO Project, USDA Organic, or Marine Stewardship Council for fish). The brand also does not disclose whether by-products or meal sources include heads, feet, or other lower-value parts, though it does claim “real” protein sources.
| Price per pound | $0.76 – $1.10 |
| Primary protein | Chicken, Chicken Meal, Lamb Meal, Beef, Salmon |
| By-products | Not disclosed |
| AAFCO compliance | Yes (no published feeding trials) |
| Formula options | 2 main lines (Loyall Life, Nutrena True) |
| Availability | Feed stores, farm supply chains (Tractor Supply), regional retailers |
Nutrena’s formulas are formulated to meet AAFCO Dog Food Nutrient Profiles for their respective life stages, but the brand does not publish whether any products have completed AAFCO feeding trials. Here’s a snapshot of representative formulas:
Protein and fat levels are competitive for mid-range kibble. The True Professional and Puppy formulas deliver high protein and fat for active, working, or growing dogs, while the maintenance formulas are leaner and more affordable for less active adults. Carbohydrate estimates are derived from guaranteed analysis (subtracting protein, fat, fiber, ash, and moisture), and they skew higher in the maintenance lines, which is typical for budget-friendly recipes.
Nutrena includes taurine, glucosamine, chondroitin, prebiotics, probiotics, and guaranteed omega fatty acids in many formulas. Vitamin and mineral fortification meets AAFCO minimums, with added vitamins A, E, D, and B-complex. The TruMune postbiotic is marketed for immune and mobility support, but without published research or dosage data, it’s hard to assess its real-world impact.
Caloric density ranges from ~345 kcal/cup in maintenance formulas to 451 kcal/cup in high-energy recipes, which is moderate to high for kibble. For a typical 30-pound adult dog needing about 900 kcal/day, you’d feed roughly 1.5 cups of True Professional or 2.5 cups of Adult Maintenance. Daily feeding costs work out to roughly $0.54 to $0.66 for a 30-pound dog, depending on formula and bag size, which is well below premium brands like Purina Pro Plan ($0.87/day) or Blue Buffalo ($1.00+/day).
Nutrena formulas meet AAFCO nutrient profiles on paper, which means they contain the minimum recommended levels of protein, fat, vitamins, and minerals for their life stage. However, meeting AAFCO standards does not guarantee digestibility, bioavailability, or clinical performance. Brands that conduct feeding trials can demonstrate that dogs actually thrive on the food over time, not just that the formula looks good on a spreadsheet. Nutrena does not publish feeding trial results, third-party nutrient analyses, or digestibility studies, so you’re relying on formulation alone.
Active and working dogs: The True Professional 30/20 and True High Energy 24/20 formulas deliver high protein and fat for stamina, muscle maintenance, and recovery. If you have a hunting dog, herding breed, or high-energy companion, these recipes offer solid nutrition at a fraction of the cost of premium performance kibbles.
Puppies: Both Loyall Life Puppy and Nutrena True Puppy provide 30–31% protein and 20% fat, with DHA for brain and eye development. The caloric density supports rapid growth, and the inclusion of glucosamine and chondroitin is a plus for large-breed puppies prone to joint issues.
Large-breed adults: Loyall Life Large Breed Adult (Chicken & Brown Rice) includes joint support and moderate fat to avoid excess weight gain, which is important for big dogs. The kibble size is larger, which encourages chewing and slows down gulpers.
Dogs with mild sensitivities: Loyall Life Advanced Solutions offers a Sensitive Skin & Coat formula (Salmon & Oatmeal) and a Healthy Digestion formula (Chicken & Brown Rice with enhanced prebiotics). These are not hydrolyzed or single-protein diets, but they avoid corn, wheat, and soy, and many owners report improvements in itching, ear infections, and stool quality.
Multi-dog households on a budget: Nutrena’s pricing is competitive, especially in 40–50 lb bags. If you’re feeding multiple dogs and need a balanced, palatable food that won’t break the bank, Loyall Life and True formulas deliver good value.
Dogs with severe food allergies or chronic gastrointestinal disease: Nutrena does not offer hydrolyzed protein, novel protein, or veterinary prescription diets. If your dog has diagnosed inflammatory bowel disease, severe pancreatitis, or confirmed protein allergies, you’ll need a specialized formula from Hill’s, Royal Canin, or Purina Pro Plan Veterinary Diets.
Dogs with heart conditions or breeds at high DCM risk: The grain-free formulas use peas, sweet potatoes, and lentils, which have been associated with DCM in some studies. If your dog is a golden retriever, Doberman, or other at-risk breed, I’d stick with grain-inclusive recipes or consult your vet before choosing grain-free.
Owners prioritizing full transparency and third-party testing: If you want to know exactly where your chicken comes from, see independent lab results for heavy metals and mycotoxins, or review published feeding trials, Nutrena won’t satisfy you. Brands like Orijen, Acana, or even Purina Pro Plan publish more data.
Very small or toy breeds with picky appetites: Nutrena’s kibble is sized for medium to large dogs, and the brand doesn’t offer small-breed-specific formulas with smaller kibble or higher caloric density. Toy breeds may struggle with the size and find the recipes less enticing than premium small-breed kibbles.
Palatability is where Nutrena generally scores well. The majority of user reviews mention that dogs “love it” or “eat it enthusiastically”, especially the chicken-based Loyall Life and True recipes. Chicken fat is a highly palatable ingredient, and the inclusion of real meat as the first ingredient likely contributes to acceptance. Beef and salmon grain-free options also get positive marks, though a smaller percentage of dogs refuse them compared to chicken.
About 70% of five-star reviews on Chewy and Amazon highlight taste and acceptance, with phrases like “my picky eater finally finished her bowl” or “both dogs cleaned their plates.” Roughly 8% of reviews mention refusal or reluctance, often after a formula change or when switching from a different brand. Some dogs take a few days to adjust, which is normal, but a small subset never warm up to it.
Nutrena offers limited flavor variety compared to premium brands. Loyall Life has chicken, lamb, beef, and salmon options; Nutrena True sticks mostly to chicken. If your dog thrives on rotation or gets bored easily, you’ll run out of options quickly. There are no exotic proteins like venison, duck, or kangaroo, and no wet food or freeze-dried toppers to add variety.
The kibble itself is standard in texture and size—not particularly small or large, not overly crunchy or soft. Large-breed formulas have bigger pieces to encourage chewing. Some owners mention a “corn” or “grain” smell, which is typical for kibble heavy on carbohydrates, but it’s not described as rancid or off-putting. A handful of reviews note a “rancid” or “chemical” smell in isolated bags, which could indicate storage issues or rare quality control lapses, but these are outliers.
Nutrena’s biggest strength is value. At roughly $0.76 to $1.10 per pound depending on formula and bag size, it undercuts most premium brands while delivering respectable protein, fat, and functional ingredients. For comparison:
For a 60-pound active dog, feeding Nutrena True Professional costs about $0.88 per day, compared to $1.45 for Purina Pro Plan Sport. Over a month, that’s a savings of roughly $17, which adds up for multi-dog households or owners on fixed incomes.
The trade-off is transparency and innovation. You’re not getting published feeding trials, third-party contaminant testing, or exotic ingredients. You’re getting solid, meat-first nutrition at a price that won’t strain your budget. If your dog does well on Nutrena, the value is excellent. If you need hypoallergenic formulas, veterinary diets, or cutting-edge research, you’ll pay more elsewhere—but you’ll also get more documentation and support.
The Loyall Life Advanced Solutions line is pricier at around $1.60/lb, which nudges it closer to Blue Buffalo and Purina Pro Plan territory. At that price point, I’d expect more transparency and variety, so the value proposition is weaker there. The core Loyall Life and True lines, however, are genuinely competitive.
Not sure whether to choose Nutrena or a budget-focused alternative? Read our Valupak dog food review to see how ultra-value brands stack up.
Nutrena is manufactured in the United States, with production facilities tied to Cargill’s network of feed mills. The brand does not publicly disclose exact plant locations for its dog food lines, which is frustrating for owners who want to verify local sourcing or audit standards. Cargill operates dozens of facilities across the Midwest and South, and Nutrena’s expansion history includes plants in Kansas, Pennsylvania, California, and a major research facility in Elk River, Minnesota.
The company claims to follow standardized quality assurance protocols across animal nutrition products, including microbiological testing, nutrient analysis, and screening for heavy metals and mycotoxins. However, Nutrena does not publish batch testing results, third-party lab reports, or audit certifications like HACCP, ISO 22000, or SQF. This is a significant gap compared to brands like Purina, Hill’s, and Royal Canin, which regularly publish quality control data and maintain visible certifications.
Nutrena has a clean recall record over the past decade, with no major FDA or USDA recalls for Salmonella, Listeria, mycotoxins, or foreign objects. This suggests consistent manufacturing standards and effective quality control, but the lack of transparency means you’re trusting Cargill’s internal processes without external verification.
Ingredient sourcing is similarly opaque. Nutrena states it sources based on “availability, quality, and Cargill’s global supplier network,” but it does not disclose country-of-origin details, supplier names, or traceability systems. You won’t find QR codes on bags linking to batch reports or ingredient maps, which is becoming more common in premium brands.
Cargill, Nutrena’s parent company, has corporate sustainability programs including greenhouse gas reduction targets, supply chain sustainability initiatives, and animal welfare guidelines. However, Nutrena does not publish brand-specific sustainability reports, environmental impact data, or third-party certifications like B Corp, Certified Humane, or Marine Stewardship Council.
Packaging is standard for the industry—polywoven plastic bags that are not widely recyclable. Some brands have moved to recyclable or compostable packaging; Nutrena has not. There’s no mention of carbon-neutral shipping, renewable energy in production, or partnerships with environmental organizations.
On animal welfare, Nutrena does not disclose sourcing standards for meat, poultry, or fish. There’s no public statement on cage-free eggs, antibiotic-free chicken, or humane slaughter practices. Cargill’s animal nutrition division emphasizes research and animal health, but specifics on ethical sourcing for pet food are absent.
The brand also does not address animal testing for product development. While feeding trials are a standard and ethical way to verify nutritional adequacy, some owners want assurance that no invasive or unnecessary testing occurs. Nutrena does not publish a policy on this.
Overall, Nutrena’s sustainability and ethics profile is below average for a modern pet food brand. If these factors are important to you, brands like Open Farm, The Honest Kitchen, or Orijen offer more transparency and third-party verification.
I work at a local dog shelter, and we occasionally test different foods with dogs who come through our doors to see how they respond before adoption families take them home. For this review, I tried Nutrena’s Loyall Life Adult Chicken & Brown Rice with a dog named Baxter, a four-year-old hound mix who arrived at the shelter a bit underweight and with a dull coat. Baxter didn’t have any diagnosed health issues, but he’d been eating inconsistent meals before coming to us, and his energy was low.
We transitioned him to Loyall Life over about five days, mixing it gradually with the generic kibble we’d been using. Baxter didn’t hesitate—he ate the new food enthusiastically from day one, which was a good sign. By the end of the first week, his stools were firmer and more consistent, and he seemed a bit more alert during playtime in the yard.
Over the next three weeks, I noticed his coat started to look shinier, especially around his chest and shoulders. It wasn’t a dramatic transformation, but the dullness was gone, and he felt softer to the touch. His energy improved, too—he went from hesitant and a bit sluggish to trotting around the yard with more confidence. His appetite stayed strong throughout, and he never refused a meal.
The only thing I didn’t love was the slight corn smell when I opened the bag, which is typical for grain-inclusive kibble but not the most appealing. Baxter didn’t seem to care, though, and his digestion stayed solid. By the time he left for his forever home, he’d gained a healthy amount of weight, his coat looked great, and his new family was happy to continue with the same food.
Overall, Baxter did well on Loyall Life. It wasn’t a miracle transformation, but it provided consistent, balanced nutrition that helped him recover from a rough start and feel like himself again.
Nutrena’s user reviews are largely positive, with weighted averages around 4.5 out of 5 stars across Chewy, Amazon, and farm supply retailer sites. The most common praise centers on palatability, coat improvements, firm stools, and value. Roughly 78% of reviews are positive, 15% neutral, and 7% negative.
Positive themes include:
Notable success stories include owners of golden retrievers, labs, and mixed breeds reporting relief from mild skin issues, fewer ear infections, and improved stamina after switching from corn-heavy grocery brands. Long-term users—some feeding Nutrena for 5+ years—report stable health and consistent quality.
Negative feedback, while less common, includes:
A handful of reviews mention formula changes in 2023–2024 that led to dogs refusing the food or experiencing digestive issues. Nutrena acknowledged updates to ingredient sourcing and nutrient profiles, but some owners felt the new recipes were less palatable or caused problems their dogs didn’t have before. This is a common complaint across the pet food industry when brands reformulate, but it’s worth noting if you’re considering Nutrena.
Customer service responses are generally helpful, with Nutrena offering refunds or replacements for quality issues. Response rates on Chewy and Amazon are around 70%, and most replies are constructive, though some owners felt the company was defensive about negative feedback on formula changes.
Nutrena occupies the value-to-mid-range segment, competing with brands like Purina ONE, Pedigree, Iams, and Diamond Naturals. It’s positioned below premium brands like Purina Pro Plan, Blue Buffalo, and Royal Canin in price and transparency, but above ultra-budget options like Ol’ Roy, Kibbles ‘n Bits, and Valupak.
Here’s how Nutrena stacks up:
Purina Pro Plan is a premium brand with extensive veterinary endorsements, published feeding trials, and third-party lab testing. Protein and fat levels are comparable (e.g., Pro Plan Sport 30/20 vs. Nutrena True Professional 30/20), but Purina offers more variety—wet food, veterinary diets, breed-specific formulas—and transparent sourcing. Purina also costs more: roughly $1.60–$2.00/lb vs. Nutrena’s $0.94–$1.10/lb. If you want maximum transparency and clinical backing, Purina wins. If you want similar macros at half the price, Nutrena is a solid alternative.
Blue Buffalo markets itself as natural and holistic, with LifeSource Bits (a blend of antioxidants, vitamins, and minerals) and no by-product meals. Protein and fat are comparable, but Blue Buffalo costs $1.20–$1.40/lb, and the brand has had multiple recalls over the years, including for excess vitamins and mold. Nutrena has a cleaner recall record and lower price, but Blue Buffalo offers more variety and a stronger marketing presence. I’d choose Nutrena for value and reliability, Blue Buffalo if you want more flavor options and don’t mind paying extra.
Diamond Naturals is a close competitor in price ($0.80–$1.20/lb) and positioning. Both brands use meat meals, grains, and added vitamins, and both appeal to budget-conscious owners. Diamond has a more varied product line, including grain-free and specialty formulas, and it publishes more nutritional data. Diamond also has a mixed recall history, including a major Salmonella recall in 2012. Nutrena’s cleaner record gives it an edge in safety, but Diamond offers more choice.
Valupak is an ultra-budget brand at $0.50–$0.75/lb, with lower protein (19–22%), lower fat (8–10%), and more grain filler. It’s aimed at price-driven, multi-dog households in rural areas. Nutrena delivers meaningfully better nutrition—higher protein, better fat sources, functional ingredients—at a modest price premium. If you can afford the extra $0.30–$0.50/lb, Nutrena is the better choice for your dog’s health.
Premium brands offer higher meat inclusion, novel proteins, transparent sourcing, third-party testing, and published research. They also cost $2.00–$4.00/lb. Nutrena can’t compete on transparency or ingredient quality, but it delivers solid, AAFCO-compliant nutrition at a fraction of the price. If your dog thrives on Nutrena, there’s no need to spend double or triple for marginal gains. If your dog has complex health needs or you prioritize ethical sourcing, premium brands justify the cost.
Nutrena is best suited for active adult dogs, working dogs, puppies, and large-breed dogs whose owners want functional nutrition without premium pricing. The True Professional and High Energy formulas are excellent for hunting dogs, herding breeds, and high-energy companions who need sustained stamina and muscle support. The puppy formulas deliver robust protein and fat for growth, with added DHA and joint support for large-breed pups.
It’s also a good fit for multi-dog households on a budget, where feeding multiple dogs premium kibble isn’t financially realistic. Nutrena delivers balanced nutrition, good palatability, and solid digestibility at a price that makes sense for volume feeding.
For dogs with mild sensitivities—occasional itching, loose stools, or ear infections—the Loyall Life Advanced Solutions line offers grain-free and sensitive-skin formulas that avoid corn, wheat, and soy. These aren’t hydrolyzed or single-protein diets, but they work for many dogs with moderate food sensitivities.
Nutrena is not ideal for dogs with severe food allergies, chronic gastrointestinal disease, heart conditions (especially if considering grain-free), or owners who prioritize full transparency and third-party testing. It’s also not the best choice for toy breeds or very picky eaters, as the kibble size and flavor variety are limited.
Nutrena is a solid, value-oriented choice for owners who want meat-first nutrition, functional ingredients, and competitive pricing without the transparency or innovation of premium brands. The True and Loyall Life lines deliver respectable protein and fat, good palatability, and a clean recall record, all at roughly half the cost of Purina Pro Plan or Blue Buffalo. For active dogs, puppies, large breeds, and multi-dog households, Nutrena offers genuine value.
That said, it’s not a brand I’d recommend if you need full transparency, published feeding trials, or third-party lab testing. The lack of sourcing details, audit certifications, and digestibility data leaves questions unanswered, and the sustainability and ethics profile is weak. If your dog has severe allergies, heart issues, or complex health needs, you’ll need a specialized formula from a premium or veterinary brand.
Would I buy this for my dog? If I had an active, healthy dog without sensitivities and I wanted to keep costs reasonable, yes—I’d feel confident feeding Nutrena True Professional or Loyall Life Adult. The ingredients are decent, the macros are competitive, and the recall record is clean. But if I had a dog with food allergies, a breed prone to DCM, or I just wanted to know exactly where my chicken came from, I’d spend more on a brand that publishes that data.
Would I recommend it to a friend? Absolutely, with context. If they’re feeding a working dog, a large-breed puppy, or multiple dogs on a budget, Nutrena is a smart choice. If they’re looking for the most transparent, research-backed, or ethically sourced option, I’d point them toward Purina Pro Plan, Hill’s, or a premium brand. Nutrena isn’t the best food on the market, but it’s far from the worst, and for the price, it delivers solid nutrition that most dogs will thrive on.
Honestly, Nutrena is a practical, no-frills option that gets the job done. It’s not going to win awards for innovation or transparency, but it’s reliable, affordable, and backed by Cargill’s resources and a clean safety record. If that’s what you need, it’s worth a shot.
Nutrena is a solid, value-oriented dog food brand that delivers meat-first nutrition at competitive prices. With over 100 years in animal nutrition and backing from Cargill, it offers reliable formulas that meet AAFCO standards. The brand has a clean recall record and includes functional ingredients like glucosamine and probiotics. However, it lacks the transparency and published feeding trials of premium brands. It’s a good choice for active dogs, puppies, and budget-conscious owners who want quality nutrition without premium pricing.
Nutrena dog food is manufactured in the United States through Cargill’s network of feed mills. The company operates facilities across the Midwest and South, with a major research facility in Elk River, Minnesota. However, Nutrena doesn’t publicly disclose the exact plant locations for its dog food lines, which limits transparency for owners who want to verify local sourcing or audit standards.
Nutrena has maintained a clean recall record over the past decade, with no major FDA or USDA recalls for Salmonella, Listeria, mycotoxins, or foreign objects. This suggests consistent manufacturing standards and effective quality control. The lack of recalls is one of Nutrena’s strengths compared to some competitors that have had multiple safety issues.
Both are Nutrena’s main dog food lines with similar quality standards. Loyall Life offers more variety including Advanced Solutions formulas for specific needs like sensitive skin or digestion, plus large-breed options. Nutrena True focuses on performance nutrition with high-protein formulas like the Professional 30/20 for active and working dogs. True tends to have higher protein and fat levels, while Loyall Life includes more specialized formulas for different life stages and sensitivities.
Daily feeding costs range from $0.54 to $0.88 per day depending on your dog’s size and the formula you choose. For a typical 30-pound dog, you’ll spend about $0.54-$0.66 daily, while a 60-pound active dog on True Professional costs around $0.88 per day. This is significantly less expensive than premium brands like Purina Pro Plan ($1.45/day) or Blue Buffalo ($1.00+/day).
Nutrena offers some options for dogs with mild sensitivities, including grain-free formulas and the Loyall Life Advanced Solutions Sensitive Skin & Coat recipe. However, it’s not recommended for dogs with severe food allergies since Nutrena doesn’t offer hydrolyzed protein, novel protein, or veterinary prescription diets. For serious allergies or chronic gastrointestinal issues, you’ll need specialized formulas from veterinary brands.
Yes, Nutrena formulas typically lead with real animal proteins like chicken, chicken meal, lamb meal, beef, or salmon as the first ingredient. The brand emphasizes “real meat first” in its marketing. However, they don’t disclose whether the meat meals come from whole animals or parts, nor do they specify suppliers or countries of origin for their protein sources.
Nutrena’s grain-free options use peas, sweet potatoes, and lentils, which have been linked to dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) in some studies. While the FDA hasn’t conclusively tied specific brands to DCM, it’s worth considering if your dog is a breed at high risk (like golden retrievers or Dobermans) or has existing heart conditions. The grain-inclusive formulas may be a safer choice for these dogs.
Nutrena isn’t widely available in regular grocery stores or big-box pet retailers. You’ll typically find it at farm supply stores, feed stores, and retailers like Tractor Supply. It’s also available online through Chewy and Amazon. The brand targets rural communities and farm supply chains rather than mainstream pet retail, which helps keep costs lower.
Both offer comparable protein and fat levels, but Purina Pro Plan costs about twice as much ($1.60-$2.00/lb vs. Nutrena’s $0.94-$1.10/lb). Pro Plan offers more transparency with published feeding trials, veterinary endorsements, and extensive variety including wet food and prescription diets. Nutrena provides similar macronutrients at half the price but lacks the clinical backing and transparency. Choose Pro Plan for maximum research support, Nutrena for similar nutrition at budget-friendly pricing.
9 out of 10 dog owners are feeding their dog the wrong food.
Take the free nutrition check and find out which food is best for your dog!
2,847+ dog owners already did
