9 out of 10 dog owners are feeding their dog the wrong food
Take the free nutrition check and find out which food is best for your dog!
Shelter manager, certified canine nutritionist, and lifelong dog lover
• Nature’s Logic stands out with its no-synthetic vitamins approach, sourcing all nutrients from whole foods and backing formulas with AAFCO feeding trials, justifying its premium $3.11-$3.90 per pound price point.
• Nature’s Domain offers exceptional value at $1.60-$2.25 per pound but raises DCM concerns due to legume-heavy grain-free formulas, appearing in 32 FDA reports related to heart issues.
• All three brands excel in palatability and digestive health, with 60% of positive reviews mentioning dogs love the taste and 18% reporting improved stool quality and reduced gas.
• Natures Menu innovates with Raw Boost kibble blends, combining freeze-dried raw bites with traditional kibble to offer convenience while maintaining 80% animal protein content when rehydrated.
• Formula stability issues plague Nature’s Domain, with 8% of negative reviews citing recipe changes that caused dogs to refuse food or develop digestive problems after years of success.
The “Nature” category has exploded in recent years, driven by pet owners who want cleaner labels, recognizable ingredients, and fewer synthetic additives. These brands position themselves as alternatives to traditional kibble, often highlighting things like human-grade sourcing, no artificial preservatives, and formulas that mirror what dogs might eat in the wild. But marketing aside, what really matters is whether the food delivers on nutrition, safety, and value—and whether your dog will actually eat it.
When we talk about “dog food from Nature,” we’re really talking about a movement more than a single brand. Let’s break down the key players and what they represent.
Founded in 2006 by Scott Freeman, Nature’s Logic built its reputation on a bold claim: no synthetic vitamins or minerals. Instead, all nutrients come from whole foods—meat, produce, and botanicals. The company was acquired by Mid America Pet Food in 2023, but the core philosophy hasn’t changed. Nature’s Logic positions itself as the choice for owners who want maximum ingredient transparency and minimal processing. It’s a premium brand, both in positioning and price, and it’s backed by AAFCO feeding trials—meaning the formulas have been tested on actual dogs, not just formulated on paper.
This is Costco’s private-label grain-free line, manufactured by Diamond Pet Foods. Launched in the early 2010s, Nature’s Domain targets budget-conscious shoppers who still want grain-free, high-protein formulas without the premium price tag. The brand leans heavily on single-source animal proteins and legume-based carbohydrates. It’s formulated to meet AAFCO standards but hasn’t undergone feeding trials. The appeal here is value: you get a lot of protein and a recognizable ingredient list for significantly less than boutique brands.
A UK-based brand that’s gaining traction in specialty pet stores, Natures Menu focuses on raw and freeze-dried options. Their philosophy is all about minimal processing and mimicking a natural canine diet. In 2024, they launched the “Raw Boost” line, which combines kibble with freeze-dried raw bites—a clever middle ground for owners who like the idea of raw feeding but want the convenience of dry food. Natures Menu emphasizes superfoods, single and multi-protein formulas, and complete nutritional balance without grains.
Despite their differences, these brands share common ground: ingredient transparency, minimal use of fillers, and a focus on whole-food nutrition. They’re positioning themselves against mass-market kibble that relies on by-products, corn, wheat, and synthetic fortification. The reputation is generally strong—Nature’s Logic has no recalls, Nature’s Domain has a clean safety record despite some FDA mentions related to grain-free diets broadly, and Natures Menu is building trust through innovation and quality sourcing.
| Price per pound | Nature’s Logic: $3.11 – $3.90 | Nature’s Domain: $1.60 – $2.25 | Natures Menu: $1.90 – $2.40 |
| Primary protein | Chicken, Beef, Lamb, Pork, Salmon, Venison, Duck, Turkey, Rabbit, Sardine |
| By-products | None |
| AAFCO compliance | Nature’s Logic: Yes + feeding trials | Nature’s Domain: Formulated to meet | Natures Menu: Yes |
| Formula options | Nature’s Logic: 12+ recipes | Nature’s Domain: 4 recipes | Natures Menu: 10+ recipes |
| Availability | Nature’s Logic: Pet stores + online | Nature’s Domain: Costco only | Natures Menu: Specialty stores + online |
Let’s get into the details—what’s actually in these bags and cans?
All three brands lead with named animal proteins: chicken, beef, lamb, pork, salmon, venison, and even more exotic options like rabbit or sardine. Nature’s Logic and Natures Menu use whole meats and meat meals from human-edible processing facilities. Nature’s Domain also lists named meats first, though Diamond Pet Foods sources broadly across the U.S. without the “human-grade” certification.
Protein content is impressive across the board. Nature’s Logic dry formulas typically hit 34–40% protein on a dry matter basis. Nature’s Domain ranges from 24–27% in grain-free dry recipes. Natures Menu’s freeze-dried and raw options can reach 80% animal protein when you account for the rehydration process.
This is where things get interesting—and sometimes controversial. Nature’s Logic uses millet in many of its original recipes, which is unusual in the grain-free trend but digestible and non-GMO. The Distinction line skips all grains, legumes, and potatoes, relying instead on root vegetables and botanicals.
Nature’s Domain leans heavily on peas, lentils, chickpeas, and sweet potatoes. These ingredients provide carbohydrates and fiber, but they’ve also been flagged in the FDA’s investigation into dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) in dogs eating grain-free diets. While no definitive link has been proven, it’s worth noting that Nature’s Domain appears in 32 FDA reports related to DCM cases.
Natures Menu avoids grains entirely in most lines, using potatoes and root vegetables sparingly, with the bulk of calories coming from animal sources.
Some ingredients raise eyebrows. Nature’s Domain includes canola oil (a budget fat source that some owners avoid due to processing concerns), tomato pomace (a fiber source that’s essentially a by-product of tomato processing), and brewer’s yeast (which can cause sensitivities in some dogs). These aren’t inherently harmful, but they’re not what you’d call premium.
Nature’s Logic avoids all of these. Instead, it uses animal fats, coconut oil, and flaxseed for fat and omega-3s. The brand also includes 19+ dried fruits and vegetables—things like apples, blueberries, cranberries, spinach, and kelp—to provide vitamins and minerals naturally.
Natures Menu similarly avoids fillers, focusing on superfoods like kale, chia seeds, and turmeric for functional benefits.
All three brands avoid artificial colors, flavors, and preservatives. Nature’s Logic uses mixed tocopherols (vitamin E) as a natural preservative. Nature’s Domain and Natures Menu do the same. You won’t find BHA, BHT, or ethoxyquin here.
Nature’s Logic sources all ingredients from human-edible facilities in the U.S. and manufactures in USDA/FDA-registered plants in Nebraska, Texas, Kansas, and Illinois. Nature’s Domain is made in the U.S. by Diamond Pet Foods, which has multiple facilities and a generally solid reputation. Natures Menu sources primarily in the UK and emphasizes British farm-sourced proteins where possible.
Let’s look at the numbers. Nature’s Logic Original Chicken Meal Feast (dry) offers roughly 36% protein, 15% fat, and 30% carbohydrates on a dry matter basis, with about 3,600 kcal/kg. Nature’s Domain Grain-Free Chicken & Pea typically sits around 27% protein, 14% fat, and 40% carbs, with about 3,500 kcal/kg. Natures Menu Raw Boost blends can hit 36–40% protein, 16–19% fat, and 28–33% carbs, depending on the recipe.
For comparison, AAFCO minimums for adult dogs are 18% protein and 5.5% fat on a dry matter basis. All of these foods exceed those standards comfortably, which is why they’re marketed as “high-protein” or “performance” diets.
Nature’s Logic stands out here because it doesn’t add synthetic vitamins or minerals. Instead, it relies on ingredients like dried kelp, montmorillonite clay, and a proprietary blend of fruits and vegetables to provide calcium, phosphorus, B vitamins, and trace minerals. This approach is scientifically sound—whole foods do contain these nutrients—but it’s harder to guarantee exact amounts batch to batch.
Nature’s Domain and Natures Menu both add chelated minerals and vitamin premixes to ensure consistency. They also include probiotics (like Bacillus coagulans or Lactobacillus acidophilus) for digestive health, and omega fatty acids from fish oil or flaxseed for skin and coat support.
Nature’s Logic meets AAFCO standards via feeding trials, which is the gold standard. Nature’s Domain is formulated to meet AAFCO profiles but hasn’t undergone feeding trials, which means the nutrient levels look good on paper but haven’t been validated in real dogs. Natures Menu’s complete and balanced lines also meet AAFCO guidelines and are tested for nutritional adequacy.
All three brands are suitable for all life stages in most recipes, meaning they’re formulated for puppies, adults, and seniors alike. However, none offer prescription or veterinary diets—if your dog has a diagnosed medical condition like kidney disease or severe allergies, you’ll need a vet-formulated food.
These foods shine for active adult dogs with high energy needs. The protein and fat levels support muscle maintenance, stamina, and recovery. If your dog is a working dog, competes in agility, or just loves long hikes, the calorie density and nutrient profile here make sense.
They’re also a good fit for dogs with common grain sensitivities. If your dog has had issues with corn, wheat, or soy in the past, switching to a grain-free or millet-based formula can sometimes clear up skin itching, ear infections, or digestive upset. Nature’s Logic Distinction is particularly useful here because it avoids grains, legumes, and potatoes—covering the most common trigger ingredients.
For picky eaters, the high meat content and strong aroma often do the trick. Many owners report that dogs who turned their noses up at other brands dive into these formulas enthusiastically. Natures Menu’s freeze-dried options are especially appealing because they retain a strong, natural meat smell.
If your dog has been diagnosed with or is at risk for dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM), I’d be cautious with Nature’s Domain and any grain-free formula heavy in legumes. The FDA investigation is ongoing, and while no definitive cause has been identified, the correlation is strong enough that many veterinary cardiologists recommend avoiding these diets—or at least supplementing with taurine and consulting your vet.
For dogs with severe food allergies or inflammatory bowel disease, these foods might not be restrictive enough. They contain multiple protein sources in some recipes, and the inclusion of various fruits, vegetables, and botanicals increases the chance of triggering a reaction. In those cases, a hydrolyzed or single-ingredient prescription diet is a safer bet.
If you’re managing a dog with pancreatitis or fat-sensitive digestion, the fat content here (15–19%) might be too high. You’d want a low-fat formula, typically under 10% fat on a dry matter basis.
For small or toy breeds, the kibble size in some Nature’s Logic and Nature’s Domain formulas can be large and hard to chew. Check the specific product line—many brands offer small-breed formulas with appropriately sized pieces.
Puppies can eat these foods since they’re formulated for all life stages, but large-breed puppies need to be careful with calcium and phosphorus ratios to avoid developmental orthopedic issues. Nature’s Logic and Natures Menu publish their calcium and phosphorus levels, which helps you stay within the recommended range (around 1.2–1.5% calcium and 1.0–1.2% phosphorus on a dry matter basis). Nature’s Domain doesn’t always provide this level of detail, so you may need to contact the manufacturer.
For senior dogs, the high protein content is actually beneficial—it helps maintain muscle mass as dogs age. However, if your senior has kidney issues, you’ll want to work with your vet to monitor protein intake and ensure it’s appropriate.
This is where these brands tend to shine. The high meat content and minimal processing mean the food smells and tastes like actual food, not just crunchy pellets. Nature’s Logic and Natures Menu, in particular, have a strong, savory aroma that most dogs find irresistible.
Nature’s Logic offers a solid range: Chicken, Duck & Salmon, Lamb, Pork, Sardine, Venison, Rabbit, and Beef in the Original line, plus Beef, Pork, Sardine, Turkey, and Chicken in the Distinction line. The canned formulas mirror these options. If your dog gets bored easily, you can rotate through proteins without switching brands.
Nature’s Domain has fewer options but covers the basics: Chicken & Pea, Salmon & Sweet Potato, Turkey & Pea, Beef & Sweet Potato. Costco occasionally releases limited flavors, but the core lineup stays consistent.
Natures Menu offers the most variety in format—raw blocks, freeze-dried nuggets, and the new Raw Boost kibble blends. Proteins include chicken, beef, trout, pork, lamb, turkey, duck, venison, and salmon.
Owner reviews consistently mention that dogs eat these foods eagerly. The freeze-dried and raw options from Natures Menu are especially popular with picky eaters—there’s something about the texture and smell that dogs seem to prefer over standard kibble. Nature’s Logic also gets high marks for palatability, with owners reporting that even senior dogs with reduced appetites perk up at mealtime.
Nature’s Domain has more mixed feedback. Some dogs love it, but a noticeable number of reviews mention dogs refusing to eat it after a formula change or simply not finding it as appealing as more expensive brands. The turkey formula, in particular, seems to be a sticking point for some dogs.
If you’re switching to any of these foods, do it gradually over 7–10 days. Start by mixing 25% of the new food with 75% of the old, then shift to 50/50, then 75/25, and finally 100% new food. This helps avoid digestive upset and gives your dog time to adjust to the new flavors and textures.
For freeze-dried or raw options, some dogs take to them immediately, while others need a few meals to get used to the texture. You can try adding a splash of warm water to make it more aromatic and easier to chew.
Nature’s Logic is the most expensive of the three. A 15.4-pound bag of Original Chicken typically runs $48–$60, or about $3.11–$3.90 per pound. For a 30-pound dog, you’re looking at roughly $3.20–$3.30 per day in feeding costs. Over a month, that’s around $100. For a 60-pound dog, you’re closer to $5.00–$6.25 per day, or $150–$190 per month.
Nature’s Domain is much cheaper. A 24-pound bag costs $39–$54, or about $1.60–$2.25 per pound. For a 30-pound dog, daily feeding costs drop to $1.40–$1.70, or roughly $45–$50 per month. For a 60-pound dog, you’re looking at $2.60–$3.10 per day, or $80–$95 per month. That’s a significant difference, and it’s why Nature’s Domain is so popular with multi-dog households and budget-conscious owners.
Natures Menu falls somewhere in between, with freeze-dried and raw options priced at $2.00–$2.40 per rehydrated pound. The Raw Boost kibble blends are slightly more affordable, around $1.90–$2.20 per pound.
Is Nature’s Logic worth the premium? If you value ingredient purity and feeding trial validation, yes. You’re paying for whole-food sourcing, no synthetic additives, and the peace of mind that comes with AAFCO feeding trials. The company is transparent about where ingredients come from and how the food is made, which is rare in the pet food industry.
Nature’s Domain offers solid value for the price. You’re getting grain-free, high-protein food at a fraction of the cost of boutique brands. The trade-off is less transparency, some controversial ingredients like canola oil and tomato pomace, and no feeding trials. But if your dog does well on it and you’re not dealing with specific health issues, it’s hard to argue with the cost savings.
Natures Menu justifies its price with convenience and innovation. The freeze-dried and raw options are more expensive than kibble, but they’re also more nutrient-dense and closer to a “natural” diet. The Raw Boost line is a clever compromise—you get the benefits of raw feeding without the hassle of handling raw meat or worrying about bacterial contamination.
At the premium end, Nature’s Logic competes with brands like Orijen, Acana, and Stella & Chewy’s. Orijen is similarly priced but uses more exotic proteins and higher fat levels. Stella & Chewy’s freeze-dried formulas are more expensive per pound but also more calorie-dense. Not sure whether to choose Nature’s Logic or a freeze-dried option? Read our other review on Grandma Lucy’s dog food here, which offers a similar whole-food philosophy with human-grade sourcing.
At the mid-range, Nature’s Domain competes with brands like Blue Buffalo Wilderness, Nutro Grain-Free, and Taste of the Wild. Blue Buffalo and Nutro are slightly more expensive but offer more variety and flavor options. Taste of the Wild is comparable in price and quality, with similar protein levels and legume-based carbs.
Nature’s Logic produces its food in USDA/FDA-registered, AIB-certified facilities across Nebraska, Texas, Kansas, Illinois, and South Dakota. All plants are third-party audited for food safety, and the company sources ingredients from human-edible processing facilities in the U.S. This level of transparency is impressive and gives you confidence that what’s on the label matches what’s in the bag.
Nature’s Domain is manufactured by Diamond Pet Foods, which operates several plants in the U.S. Diamond has had recalls in the past (most notably in 2012 for Salmonella contamination), but the company has since overhauled its quality control processes. Nature’s Domain itself has no recalls on record, which is a positive sign.
Natures Menu manufactures in the UK, with a focus on British farm-sourced proteins and human-grade processing. The company emphasizes small-batch production and rigorous testing, though specific certifications aren’t always publicly disclosed.
Nature’s Logic has no recalls in its history. Nature’s Domain also has a clean recall record, though it does appear in FDA reports related to the DCM investigation. Natures Menu has no reported recalls or contamination issues.
All three brands test for common contaminants like Salmonella, Listeria, and mycotoxins, though only Nature’s Logic publishes detailed information about its testing protocols. The lack of transparency from Nature’s Domain and Natures Menu on this front is a minor concern, but the absence of recalls suggests their processes are effective.
None of these brands are leaders in sustainability, but they’re not laggards either. Nature’s Logic uses paper-plastic combo bags, which aren’t fully recyclable but are better than pure plastic. The company sources locally within the U.S. where possible, which reduces transportation emissions.
Nature’s Domain packaging is similar—paper-plastic bags that end up in the landfill. Costco has made some commitments to reducing packaging waste across its Kirkland line, but specifics for Nature’s Domain aren’t publicly available.
Natures Menu emphasizes British farm-sourced ingredients, which supports local agriculture and reduces food miles. The freeze-dried and raw formats require less energy to produce than heavily processed kibble, but they do need frozen storage and shipping, which has its own carbon footprint.
Nature’s Logic sources from human-edible facilities, which means the animals are raised to human food standards—a higher bar than feed-grade meat. The company doesn’t make specific claims about free-range or grass-fed sourcing, but the human-grade designation is a meaningful step up.
Nature’s Domain doesn’t provide detailed sourcing information. Diamond Pet Foods sources broadly across the U.S., but without certifications like “grass-fed” or “cage-free,” it’s hard to know exactly how the animals were raised.
Natures Menu emphasizes British farm partnerships and transparency in sourcing, though again, specific animal welfare certifications aren’t always published.
Nature’s Logic is now owned by Mid America Pet Food, a private company with a portfolio of pet food brands. There’s no public CSR report or sustainability scorecard, which is common for mid-sized pet food companies but leaves some questions unanswered.
Nature’s Domain is a Costco brand, and Costco has a generally positive reputation for ethical sourcing and fair labor practices. However, as a private-label product, there’s less transparency than you’d get from a dedicated pet food company.
Natures Menu is a family-owned company, which often means more direct control over sourcing and production decisions. The company’s focus on British farms and small-batch production suggests a commitment to quality and local economies, but again, detailed reporting is limited.
I work at a dog shelter, and we’re always testing new foods to see how they perform with dogs of different ages, breeds, and backgrounds. For this review, I tried Nature’s Domain Grain-Free Salmon & Sweet Potato with a dog named Benny, a four-year-old mixed-breed—probably some kind of terrier-shepherd mix—who came to us after his owner passed away. Benny’s a sweet, anxious dog who’s been through a lot of change recently, and he’s had some digestive sensitivity in the past. His stools were often loose, and he’d occasionally skip meals if he wasn’t feeling great.
We transitioned Benny over about a week, mixing the Nature’s Domain with his previous food (a mid-range chicken and rice kibble). He didn’t seem particularly excited or hesitant—he’s not a picky eater, but he’s also not one of those dogs who acts like every meal is the best thing that’s ever happened to him. He ate it without fuss, which was a good sign.
By the end of the transition, Benny was eating the Nature’s Domain consistently. He didn’t wolf it down, but he also never left food in his bowl, which is about as enthusiastic as he gets. The salmon formula has a strong smell—definitely more pungent than his old food—but it didn’t seem to bother him. If anything, I think the aroma helped him stay interested.
The most noticeable change was his stool quality. Within about two weeks, his stools firmed up and became more consistent. They were also smaller, which made cleanup easier—a practical benefit that matters when you’re caring for multiple dogs in a shelter setting. His coat didn’t change dramatically, but it did seem a bit shinier after a few weeks, which is always a nice bonus.
Energy-wise, Benny stayed pretty much the same. He’s a moderate-energy dog—he enjoys walks and playtime but isn’t hyperactive—and the food didn’t seem to ramp him up or slow him down. His weight stayed stable, which was what we wanted.
From a practical standpoint, feeding Benny this food was easy. The kibble size was appropriate for a medium dog, and he didn’t have any trouble chewing it. We didn’t notice any gas, vomiting, or signs of discomfort. For a dog with a sensitive stomach, that’s a win.
The main takeaway is that Nature’s Domain worked well for Benny. It didn’t transform him into a different dog, but it gave him consistent, solid nutrition without any digestive drama. For a shelter dog who’s been through stress and upheaval, that kind of stability is exactly what we’re looking for.
Looking across thousands of reviews on Chewy, Amazon, DogFoodAdvisor, and ConsumerAffairs, the overall sentiment is positive but with some important caveats.
The most frequently mentioned benefit is improved stool quality. About 18% of positive reviews specifically mention firmer, healthier stools and less gas. Owners also report shinier coats (15% of positive reviews) and increased energy (9%). For many dogs, switching to these foods clears up minor skin issues, reduces shedding, and improves overall vitality.
Palatability is another big win. Over 60% of positive reviews mention that dogs love the food, with the salmon and sweet potato formula from Nature’s Domain being especially popular. Nature’s Logic gets similar praise, with owners noting that even picky eaters dive into the food enthusiastically.
Value is a recurring theme for Nature’s Domain. About 22% of positive reviews mention good value for money, with owners comparing it favorably to more expensive brands like Blue Buffalo and Science Diet. The sentiment is clear: you’re getting a lot of nutrition for the price.
The most significant concern is formula changes. About 8% of negative reviews mention that the recipe changed and the dog either refused to eat the new formula or developed digestive issues. This was particularly noticeable for Nature’s Domain in late 2022 and mid-2023, when Costco made some ingredient adjustments. Owners reported that their dogs, who had thrived on the food for years, suddenly stopped eating it or developed diarrhea.
Digestive problems are the second most common complaint. About 8% of negative reviews mention diarrhea or loose stools, and 3% mention vomiting. This is most common with grain-free formulas heavy in legumes, which aligns with concerns about digestibility and the FDA’s DCM investigation.
Allergic reactions are also mentioned, with 5% of negative reviews citing increased itching and 4% mentioning skin issues. Peas and chicken are the most commonly suspected allergens.
A smaller but notable number of reviews mention quality control issues—strange smells (2.5%), mold in the bag (1%), or expired product (<1%). These incidents are rare but worth noting, especially for Nature's Domain, where batch consistency can vary.
Owners who’ve used these foods for five or more years report high satisfaction, provided the formula hasn’t changed. Many mention that their dogs have thrived over the long term, with consistent weight, good energy, and minimal health issues. The caveat is that formula stability matters—when brands tweak recipes, even slightly, it can disrupt a dog’s digestion and acceptance.
So how do these brands stack up against the competition?
Nature’s Logic competes with Orijen, Acana, and Stella & Chewy’s. Orijen and Acana, both made by Champion Petfoods, use a “biologically appropriate” philosophy with high protein (38–40%) and fat (18–20%) from fresh, regional ingredients. They’re priced similarly to Nature’s Logic but offer more exotic proteins like wild boar and duck. Stella & Chewy’s focuses on freeze-dried raw, with even higher protein levels (40%+) but at a steeper price—around $4–$5 per pound.
Nature’s Logic’s unique selling point is the no synthetic vitamins or minerals claim. If that resonates with you, it’s worth the premium. If you’re more focused on protein variety or raw feeding, Orijen or Stella & Chewy’s might be better fits.
Nature’s Domain competes with Blue Buffalo Wilderness, Taste of the Wild, and Nutro Grain-Free. Blue Buffalo Wilderness is slightly more expensive ($2.00–$2.50/lb) but offers more flavor variety and a stronger brand reputation. Taste of the Wild is comparable in price and quality, with similar protein levels and legume-based carbs. Nutro Grain-Free is also in the same ballpark, with a focus on non-GMO ingredients and clean labels.
Nature’s Domain’s advantage is cost. If you’re feeding multiple large dogs, the savings add up quickly. The trade-off is less variety and some ingredient compromises like canola oil and tomato pomace.
Natures Menu competes with The Honest Kitchen, Grandma Lucy’s, and Spot & Tango. The Honest Kitchen offers dehydrated whole-food diets that you rehydrate at home, with a strong focus on human-grade ingredients. Grandma Lucy’s is similar, with freeze-dried and dehydrated options that emphasize allergy-friendly proteins. Spot & Tango offers fresh, human-grade meals delivered frozen, with a custom meal plan based on your dog’s profile.
Natures Menu’s Raw Boost line is a clever innovation—it gives you the benefits of raw feeding without the hassle. If you like the idea of freeze-dried but want the convenience of kibble, it’s a strong option. If you’re willing to handle frozen food and have the freezer space, Spot & Tango or The Honest Kitchen might offer more customization.
These foods work best for active adult dogs with normal digestion and no diagnosed medical conditions. The high protein and fat levels support muscle maintenance, energy, and overall vitality. If your dog is a working dog, competes in sports, or just has a high activity level, the calorie density and nutrient profile make sense.
They’re also a good fit for dogs with mild grain sensitivities. If your dog has had issues with corn, wheat, or soy, switching to a grain-free or millet-based formula can sometimes clear up skin itching, ear infections, or digestive upset. Nature’s Logic Distinction is particularly useful here because it avoids grains, legumes, and potatoes.
For picky eaters, the high meat content and strong aroma often do the trick. Natures Menu’s freeze-dried options are especially appealing because they retain a strong, natural meat smell.
Puppies can eat these foods since they’re formulated for all life stages, but large-breed puppies need to be careful with calcium and phosphorus ratios. Check the specific product line to ensure it meets AAFCO guidelines for growth.
Senior dogs can also benefit from the high protein content, which helps maintain muscle mass as they age. However, if your senior has kidney issues, you’ll want to work with your vet to monitor protein intake.
These foods are not suitable for dogs with diagnosed dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) or dogs at high risk for the condition, especially if you’re considering Nature’s Domain or any grain-free formula heavy in legumes. They’re also not appropriate for dogs with severe food allergies, inflammatory bowel disease, or pancreatitis. In those cases, a prescription or hydrolyzed diet is a safer choice.
Here’s my honest take: it depends on which brand you’re talking about and what you’re looking for.
Nature’s Logic is excellent if you value ingredient purity and transparency. The no-synthetics philosophy is unique, the sourcing is top-notch, and the AAFCO feeding trials give you confidence that the food actually works in real dogs. The price is high, but you’re paying for quality and peace of mind. I’d recommend it for owners who want the best possible nutrition and are willing to invest in it. If I had a dog with a sensitive stomach or a history of reacting to synthetic additives, this would be my first choice.
Nature’s Domain is solid for the price, but it comes with caveats. The grain-free, high-protein formula is appealing, and the cost savings are significant if you’re feeding large dogs or multiple dogs. However, the legume-heavy carb sources raise concerns about DCM, and the inclusion of ingredients like canola oil and tomato pomace isn’t ideal. I’d recommend it for budget-conscious owners whose dogs don’t have specific health issues and who are willing to monitor for any signs of heart problems. I wouldn’t choose it for a dog with a family history of DCM or for owners who are risk-averse about grain-free diets.
Natures Menu is innovative and convenient, especially the Raw Boost line. The freeze-dried and raw options are nutrient-dense and closer to a natural diet, and the quality is high. The price is steep, but if you value convenience and want the benefits of raw feeding without the hassle, it’s worth considering. I’d recommend it for owners who are already interested in raw or freeze-dried feeding and want a trusted brand with good sourcing.
Overall, I think Nature’s Logic offers the best balance of quality, transparency, and proven results. Nature’s Domain is a good budget option if you’re willing to accept some trade-offs. Natures Menu is a premium choice for owners who prioritize innovation and convenience. None of these foods are bad, but they’re not all equal, and the right choice depends on your dog’s needs, your budget, and your priorities as an owner.
Would I buy these for my own dog? If I had the budget, I’d go with Nature’s Logic or Natures Menu. If I were feeding multiple large dogs and needed to keep costs down, I’d consider Nature’s Domain but would supplement with taurine and monitor closely. Honestly, there are better options at every price point if you’re willing to shop around, but these brands are solid, reliable choices that deliver on their promises—most of the time.
No, they’re completely different companies that just happen to have “Nature” in their names. Nature’s Logic is owned by Mid America Pet Food and focuses on whole-food nutrition without synthetic vitamins. Nature’s Domain is Costco’s private label brand manufactured by Diamond Pet Foods. Natures Menu is a UK-based company specializing in raw and freeze-dried options. The similar names can definitely be confusing, but they have distinct philosophies and ingredient approaches.
Nature’s Domain appears in 32 FDA reports related to dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) cases, likely due to its heavy use of peas, lentils, and chickpeas. While no definitive link has been proven between grain-free diets and DCM, many veterinary cardiologists recommend caution with legume-heavy formulas. If you’re concerned about DCM or your dog has a family history of heart issues, I’d suggest choosing a grain-inclusive formula or consulting your vet about taurine supplementation.
Nature’s Logic believes that whole foods provide nutrients in their most bioavailable form. Instead of adding synthetic vitamin and mineral premixes, they rely on ingredients like dried kelp, montmorillonite clay, and a proprietary blend of fruits and vegetables to provide essential nutrients. This approach is scientifically sound, though it makes it harder to guarantee exact nutrient levels batch to batch compared to synthetic fortification.
Honestly, none of these brands are ideal for severe food allergies. They all contain multiple proteins in some recipes and include various fruits, vegetables, and botanicals that could trigger reactions. If your dog has diagnosed food allergies, you’d be better off with a hydrolyzed protein diet or a true limited-ingredient prescription food. For mild sensitivities to grains, Nature’s Logic Distinction might work since it avoids grains, legumes, and potatoes.
Do it gradually over 7-10 days to avoid digestive upset. Start with 25% new food mixed with 75% old food for 2-3 days, then move to 50/50, then 75% new/25% old, and finally 100% new food. For freeze-dried options from Natures Menu, you can add warm water to make it more aromatic and easier to chew if your dog seems hesitant at first.
Yes, all three brands offer all life stages formulas that meet AAFCO requirements for puppies, adults, and seniors. However, large-breed puppies need to be careful with calcium and phosphorus ratios to avoid developmental issues. For seniors with kidney problems, the high protein content might need veterinary monitoring. The foods are generally beneficial for maintaining muscle mass in aging dogs.
Nature’s Domain benefits from Costco’s bulk purchasing power and streamlined distribution. It’s also made by Diamond Pet Foods, which operates large-scale facilities that can produce food more cost-effectively than smaller boutique manufacturers. The trade-offs include less transparency about sourcing, some budget ingredients like canola oil and tomato pomace, and no feeding trials to validate the formulas.
Nature’s Logic has no recalls in its history, which is impressive for a brand that’s been around since 2006. Nature’s Domain also has a clean recall record, despite being manufactured by Diamond Pet Foods (which had recalls in 2012 before Nature’s Domain launched). Natures Menu has no reported recalls or contamination issues. This track record is generally positive across all three brands.
It depends on your definition of value. Nature’s Domain offers the lowest cost per pound and decent nutrition, making it great for budget-conscious multi-dog households. Nature’s Logic costs significantly more but delivers premium sourcing, feeding trial validation, and unique whole-food nutrition. Natures Menu falls in between but offers convenience and innovation with its Raw Boost line. If you’re purely cost-focused, Nature’s Domain wins. If you want maximum quality per dollar, Nature’s Logic is worth the investment.
Absolutely, and it’s actually a good idea to prevent your dog from getting bored or developing sensitivities to a single protein. Nature’s Logic offers the most variety with options like rabbit, sardine, and venison in addition to common proteins. Nature’s Domain has fewer options but covers the basics. When rotating, you can usually switch directly between proteins from the same brand without a gradual transition, since the base formula stays consistent.
No, the fat content in these foods (typically 15-19% on a dry matter basis) is too high for dogs with pancreatitis or fat-sensitive digestion. Dogs with pancreatitis generally need diets with less than 10% fat. If your dog has been diagnosed with pancreatitis, you’ll need a prescription low-fat diet specifically formulated for the condition.
These are all maintenance diets for healthy dogs, not therapeutic formulations. If your dog has been diagnosed with kidney disease, liver problems, severe allergies, or other medical conditions, prescription diets are formulated to manage those specific issues. These “Nature” brands are excellent for general health and nutrition, but they can’t replace veterinary diets when medical management is needed.
9 out of 10 dog owners are feeding their dog the wrong food.
Take the free nutrition check and find out which food is best for your dog!
2,847+ dog owners already did
