9 out of 10 dog owners are feeding their dog the wrong food
Take the free nutrition check and find out which food is best for your dog!
Shelter manager, certified canine nutritionist, and lifelong dog lover
• Budget-friendly nutrition: At $0.47 per 1,000 kcal, Iams delivers AAFCO-compliant large breed puppy nutrition at roughly half the cost of premium competitors like Blue Buffalo.
• Grain-heavy formula with by-product meal: While chicken is listed first, most protein comes from chicken by-product meal, with an estimated 49% carbohydrate content from corn and other grains.
• Safe calcium levels for large breeds: Formula contains exactly 1.2% calcium and 0.9% phosphorus, meeting AAFCO’s strict requirements to prevent skeletal problems in growing large breed puppies.
• Mixed digestive tolerance: Most puppies enjoy the taste and show improved coat condition, but about 10% of owners report digestive upset including loose stools and gas.
• Clean safety record: No recalls since 2013, with over a decade of incident-free production, though the brand lacks transparency about ingredient sourcing and quality control processes.
When you flip over that Iams bag, the first ingredient you’ll see is chicken. That’s a good start—real animal protein leading the list is what you want to see in any puppy food. But here’s where things get a bit less impressive: the second ingredient is ground whole grain corn, followed quickly by chicken by-product meal. That by-product meal is where most of the actual protein content is coming from, not that fresh chicken listed first.
Chicken by-product meal isn’t dangerous or toxic, but it’s a lower-quality protein source compared to named muscle meats. It includes organ meats, feet, and other parts left after the desirable cuts are removed. The nutritional value can vary batch to batch depending on what goes into the mix. If you’re comparing this to premium brands that use deboned chicken or chicken meal as their primary proteins, Iams is taking a more budget-friendly approach here.
The formula also relies heavily on grains—corn, sorghum, and brewers rice all make appearances. These aren’t inherently bad (and they’re not linked to the diet-associated DCM concerns that grain-free foods have faced), but they do push the carbohydrate content higher than you’d find in meat-focused formulas. The estimated carbohydrate level sits around 49% on a dry matter basis, which is on the high end for a puppy food.
A few additions do stand out in a positive way. The formula includes fish oil as a source of omega-3 fatty acids and DHA, which supports brain and eye development in growing puppies. You’ll also find dried egg, a highly digestible protein source, and natural flavor, which helps with palatability (and based on customer reviews, most puppies do find this food tasty).
On the joint-support front, Iams includes glucosamine (350 mg/kg) and chondroitin (35 mg/kg), which are important for large breed puppies prone to hip and joint issues as they grow. The levels aren’t exceptionally high, but they’re present and meet the baseline you’d expect for a large breed puppy formula.
What you won’t find here are probiotics, prebiotics beyond beet pulp, or any of the trendy superfood ingredients like blueberries or sweet potatoes. The minerals used are standard forms, not chelated versions, which means they may not be absorbed as efficiently as the premium chelated minerals you’d see in higher-end foods. If your puppy has specific digestive sensitivities or you’re looking for a formula packed with functional ingredients, this one keeps things pretty basic.
| Price per pound | $0.98 – $1.15 |
| Primary protein | Chicken |
| By-products | Yes (chicken by-product meal) |
| AAFCO compliance | Yes (large breed puppy standards) |
| Formula options | Large breed puppy formula only |
| Availability | Widely available (pet stores + online) |
On an as-fed basis, Iams Large Breed Puppy delivers 28% crude protein and 14% crude fat. When you adjust for moisture and look at the dry matter basis, that translates to roughly 31% protein and 16% fat. Both numbers comfortably exceed AAFCO’s minimum requirements for large breed puppy growth (22.5% protein and 8.5% fat), so from a regulatory standpoint, this food checks the necessary boxes.
The protein level is solid for a puppy food, though it’s not exceptional compared to premium competitors. Brands like Blue Buffalo and Purina Pro Plan for large breed puppies hover in a similar range, so Iams isn’t lagging behind here. The fat content is moderate—enough to support energy needs and coat health without pushing calories too high, which is important for large breeds that need controlled growth to protect developing joints.
This is where large breed puppy formulas really matter. Excessive calcium during the rapid growth phase can lead to skeletal problems, so AAFCO sets stricter guidelines for large breed puppies: calcium must fall between 1.2% and 1.8%, and phosphorus between 0.8% and 1.6%. Iams hits 1.2% calcium and 0.9% phosphorus, landing right at the minimum for calcium and comfortably within range for phosphorus.
That’s a safe, conservative approach. It won’t over-mineralize your puppy’s diet, which is exactly what you want for a Great Dane, Labrador, or German Shepherd in their first year of life.
With an estimated 49% carbohydrate content on a dry matter basis, this formula is noticeably carb-heavy. That’s the trade-off when grains like corn, sorghum, and rice make up a significant portion of the recipe. The 4% crude fiber (about 4.4% dry matter basis) is moderate and should support healthy digestion without causing issues for most puppies.
If your puppy tends toward loose stools or you’re aiming for a lower-carb, higher-protein diet, this might not be your first choice. But for the average healthy large breed puppy, the carb level isn’t a dealbreaker—it just means you’re feeding a more grain-forward formula.
Iams has had a few recalls over the years, but nothing recent or severe. Back in December 2011, certain batches of Iams ProActive Health Smart Puppy were recalled due to aflatoxin contamination (a toxin produced by mold). The recall was limited to specific lot codes in the eastern U.S., and no illnesses were reported. In August 2013, Iams (along with Eukanuba, a sister brand) issued a recall for potential Salmonella contamination detected during routine testing. Again, the recall was precautionary, and no confirmed illnesses resulted.
Since then, there have been no recalls tied to Iams large breed puppy food as of late 2025. That’s a reassuring track record for a brand that’s been on the market for decades. While no brand is immune to manufacturing issues, Iams has maintained a clean slate for over a decade, which speaks to improved quality control measures.
Iams is owned by Mars, Inc., one of the largest pet food conglomerates in the world. The brand manufactures in the U.S., though some products may be imported or use ingredients sourced internationally. The packaging states “Made in the USA or Imported,” which is somewhat vague but common for large-scale manufacturers.
What’s less clear is the level of transparency around ingredient sourcing, testing protocols, and nutritionist credentials. Iams doesn’t publicly share detailed information about where their chicken comes from, whether they conduct third-party testing for heavy metals or contaminants, or who formulates their recipes. Compared to brands that openly discuss their veterinary nutritionists and quality assurance processes, Iams keeps things fairly corporate and opaque.
Blue Buffalo positions itself as a more natural, premium option. Its large breed puppy formula features deboned chicken as the first ingredient (not by-product meal), includes LifeSource Bits (a blend of antioxidants and nutrients), and uses brown rice and barley instead of corn. The protein and fat levels are similar to Iams, but the ingredient quality is noticeably higher. The trade-off? Blue Buffalo costs about $0.68 per 1,000 kcal compared to Iams’ $0.47. If ingredient transparency and whole-food sources matter to you, Blue Buffalo is worth the extra cost. If budget is tight and you’re feeding a large or giant breed, Iams delivers similar macros at a significantly lower price.
Purina Pro Plan is another mainstream competitor, and it sits somewhere between Iams and Blue Buffalo in terms of both quality and price. Pro Plan uses chicken as the first ingredient and includes DHA from fish oil and antioxidants for immune support. The protein and fat content are comparable to Iams, but Purina has a stronger reputation for research-backed formulas and veterinary endorsements. It costs around $0.60 per 1,000 kcal, making it a middle-ground option. If you want a bit more confidence in the science behind the food without jumping to premium pricing, Pro Plan is a solid alternative.
If you’re considering grain-free large breed puppy foods, it’s worth noting that Iams is not grain-free and doesn’t try to be. Given the FDA’s investigation into potential links between grain-free diets and dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) in dogs, especially those heavy in legumes like peas and lentils, Iams’ grain-inclusive formula may actually be the safer choice for some owners. Grain-free doesn’t automatically mean better, and for large breed puppies, controlled nutrition matters more than trendy ingredient lists.
Across platforms like Chewy and Walmart, Iams Large Breed Puppy food averages around 4.2 to 4.5 out of 5 stars, with about 65% of reviewers giving it five stars. The most common praise centers on affordability—owners appreciate being able to feed a large or giant breed puppy without breaking the bank. Many also report that their puppies love the taste and eagerly finish their meals, which is a relief if you’ve ever dealt with a picky eater.
Several reviewers mention visible improvements in their puppy’s coat condition, noting shinier, softer fur after a few weeks on the food. Others appreciate the larger kibble size, which encourages big-breed puppies to chew thoroughly rather than gulping down their food. For owners of Labs, Golden Retrievers, and German Shepherds, these practical benefits make Iams a go-to choice.
On the flip side, about 10% of reviews are one-star, and the complaints tend to focus on digestive upset. Some owners report that their puppies experienced loose stools, gas, or diarrhea after switching to Iams. This isn’t universal, but it’s common enough to be a pattern. If your puppy has a sensitive stomach or a history of food intolerances, you’ll want to transition slowly and monitor closely.
A smaller subset of owners also mention that their puppies refused to eat the food or lost interest after a few days. Taste is subjective, and while most dogs seem to enjoy Iams, there are always picky eaters who won’t cooperate. Finally, some reviewers express concern over the inclusion of by-products and corn, wishing the formula relied more on whole meats and vegetables. That’s more of a philosophical issue than a nutritional one, but it’s worth noting if ingredient quality is a priority for you.
Iams Large Breed Puppy food makes the most sense for owners of healthy, non-sensitive large breed puppies who need a budget-friendly option that meets AAFCO standards. If you’re raising a Lab, Golden Retriever, Rottweiler, or German Shepherd and your puppy has no history of food allergies or digestive issues, this formula will get the job done. It’s widely available, reasonably priced, and nutritionally adequate for supporting growth without over-mineralizing the diet.
It’s also a practical choice if you’re feeding multiple dogs or a giant breed that goes through food quickly. The larger bag sizes and lower cost per calorie mean you can keep your puppy fed without constantly worrying about your budget. For many owners, that peace of mind is worth more than a few premium ingredients.
This food isn’t the best fit for puppies with known sensitivities to chicken, corn, or soy. All three are present in the formula, and if your puppy has shown signs of allergies or intolerances in the past, you’ll want to look for a limited-ingredient or novel-protein diet instead. Similarly, if your puppy has a sensitive stomach or a history of digestive issues, the grain-heavy formula and by-product meal may not sit well.
Iams also explicitly states that this food is not for pregnant or nursing dogs, so if you’re raising a litter, you’ll need a different formula. And if you’re the type of owner who prioritizes whole-food ingredients, probiotics, and premium sourcing, this formula will feel too basic. You’re better off investing in a brand like Blue Buffalo, Orijen, or Wellness that aligns with those values.
Not sure whether to choose Iams for weight management? Read our other review on Iams healthy weight dog food review to see how the brand handles adult dogs with specific dietary needs.
At around $0.47 per 1,000 kcal, Iams Large Breed Puppy is one of the most affordable options in the large breed puppy category. A 30.6-pound bag typically retails for about $30 to $35, which translates to roughly $0.17 per 100 grams. For comparison, Blue Buffalo runs closer to $0.68 per 1,000 kcal, and Purina Pro Plan sits around $0.60.
If you’re feeding a 70-pound Labrador puppy, you’re looking at roughly 3 to 4 cups per day, which means a 30-pound bag will last about three to four weeks. That’s a manageable expense for most households, especially when you compare it to premium brands that can cost nearly double. The value proposition here is straightforward: you’re getting AAFCO-compliant nutrition at a price that won’t strain your budget.
Iams doesn’t publicly disclose much about its sustainability practices, animal welfare standards, or environmental impact. There are no certifications like MSC (Marine Stewardship Council) for fish oil sourcing, no organic claims, and no transparency around carbon footprint or packaging recyclability. If you’re an owner who prioritizes eco-friendly and ethically sourced pet food, this is a gap you’ll notice.
That said, the brand is owned by Mars, Inc., which has made some corporate commitments to sustainability across its portfolio. Whether those commitments trickle down to ingredient sourcing and manufacturing for Iams specifically is unclear. For most buyers, this won’t be a dealbreaker, but it’s worth mentioning for those who want to make informed ethical choices.
Iams ProActive Health Smart Puppy Large Breed is a solid, no-frills option for large breed puppies that hits the nutritional marks without demanding a premium price. It’s not going to wow you with exotic proteins or superfood ingredients, and the reliance on by-product meal and grains will turn off some owners. But for the average healthy puppy, it delivers adequate protein, controlled calcium and phosphorus, and joint-supporting nutrients at a price point that makes feeding a giant breed manageable.
The safety record is clean, the taste is generally well-received, and the formula meets AAFCO standards for large breed growth. If your puppy has no sensitivities and you’re looking for a budget-friendly food that gets the job done, Iams is a reliable choice. Just don’t expect premium ingredient quality or cutting-edge formulation—you’re paying for functional nutrition, not luxury.
For owners who want more transparency, higher-quality proteins, or added functional ingredients like probiotics, it’s worth spending a bit more on brands like Blue Buffalo or Purina Pro Plan. But if your priority is affordability and availability, Iams Large Breed Puppy food is a practical, dependable option that will support your puppy’s growth without emptying your wallet.
Yes, Iams has maintained a clean safety record for over a decade. Their last recalls were in 2011 (aflatoxin) and 2013 (Salmonella), both handled as precautionary measures with no reported illnesses. Since then, there have been no recalls tied to Iams large breed puppy food as of late 2025. The brand has clearly improved their quality control measures over the years.
Chicken by-product meal is a cost-cutting measure that helps keep Iams affordable. While it’s not dangerous, it’s a lower-quality protein source that includes organ meats, feet, and other parts left after desirable cuts are removed. The nutritional value can vary batch to batch. If you want more consistent, higher-quality protein sources, you’ll need to spend more on premium brands that use deboned chicken or named muscle meats.
Feeding amounts depend on your puppy’s current weight and target adult weight, but generally expect 3 to 4 cups per day for a puppy that will reach 70 pounds as an adult. Always follow the feeding guidelines on the package and adjust based on your puppy’s body condition. Large breed puppies need controlled growth, so don’t overfeed—excess calories can lead to joint problems later in life.
It might not be the best choice. About 10% of customer reviews mention digestive upset including loose stools, gas, or diarrhea. The grain-heavy formula and by-product meal can be harder to digest for sensitive puppies. If your puppy has a history of stomach issues, you’ll want to transition slowly and consider a limited-ingredient diet instead.
Yes, Iams hits 1.2% calcium and 0.9% phosphorus, which lands right within AAFCO’s guidelines for large breed puppies (1.2-1.8% calcium). This conservative approach helps prevent over-mineralization that can lead to skeletal problems during rapid growth phases. The formula also includes glucosamine and chondroitin for additional joint support, though the levels aren’t exceptionally high.
Iams costs about $0.47 per 1,000 kcal compared to Blue Buffalo’s $0.68. Blue Buffalo uses higher-quality ingredients like deboned chicken and includes LifeSource Bits with antioxidants, but both foods deliver similar protein and fat levels. If budget is your main concern and your puppy has no sensitivities, Iams will do the job. If ingredient quality matters more than cost, Blue Buffalo is worth the premium.
No, Iams explicitly states this formula is not for pregnant or nursing dogs. Breeding females have different nutritional requirements than growing puppies. You’ll need a different formula specifically designed for reproduction or an all-life-stages food that meets those higher nutritional demands.
The high carb content comes from the grain-heavy ingredient list—corn, sorghum, and brewers rice all make significant contributions. This is typical for budget-friendly foods where grains are used to provide affordable calories and energy. While it’s not harmful, it does mean you’re feeding a more grain-forward formula rather than a meat-focused one. If you prefer lower-carb diets, you’ll need to look at premium brands.
Most puppies seem to love the taste—customer reviews consistently mention that puppies eagerly finish their meals. The formula includes natural flavor for palatability. However, there are always exceptions, and some reviewers mention their puppies refused to eat it or lost interest after a few days. Taste is subjective, so you might need to try it and see how your individual puppy responds.
Yes, the controlled calcium and phosphorus levels make it suitable for giant breeds that need careful growth management. The larger kibble size also encourages proper chewing rather than gulping, which is important for deep-chested breeds prone to bloat. Just remember that giant breed puppies will go through food quickly, so factor the cost of feeding a dog that might eat 6-8 cups per day as they approach their adult size.
9 out of 10 dog owners are feeding their dog the wrong food.
Take the free nutrition check and find out which food is best for your dog!
2,847+ dog owners already did
