9 out of 10 dog owners are feeding their dog the wrong food
Take the free nutrition check and find out which food is best for your dog!
Shelter manager, certified canine nutritionist, and lifelong dog lover
• Fifth-generation family business with complete in-house manufacturing control in Wisconsin facilities, resulting in exceptional quality consistency and a remarkably clean recall record compared to competitors using co-packers.
• Outstanding palatability success rate of 78% among dog owners, making it particularly effective for picky eaters who consistently refuse other premium brands.
• Three-tiered pricing strategy from affordable Classics ($1.08/lb) to premium Four-Star ($2.32/lb), though large dog owners face significant monthly costs up to $150 on top-tier formulas.
• Rotational feeding philosophy with interchangeable recipes across protein sources, supported by consistent nutritional profiles that prevent digestive upset when switching between flavors within product lines.
• Notable gaps in sustainability transparency with no environmental impact reporting, non-recyclable packaging, and limited animal welfare information despite strong ingredient quality and manufacturing practices.
Fromm Family Foods isn’t some corporate conglomerate that bought a cute name and slapped it on a bag. This is a genuine fifth-generation family business that’s been operating since 1904, starting with the four Fromm brothers in Wisconsin. What began as a fur farm eventually evolved into pioneering animal health—they developed the first canine distemper vaccine in the 1930s—and by 1949, they launched their first bag of complete dog food. That’s over 75 years of pet nutrition experience, and the family still runs the company today.
What I find impressive about Fromm is their insistence on manufacturing everything in-house. They own and operate all their facilities in Wisconsin—Mequon, Columbus, Eden, and Germantown—which gives them complete control over ingredient sourcing, production standards, and quality checks. In an industry where co-packing is common and quality can vary wildly between batches made at different plants, Fromm’s approach stands out. They’re not outsourcing to the lowest bidder; they’re keeping production under one roof and one family’s oversight.
Fromm positions itself as a premium brand with a focus on variety, quality, and rotational feeding. The idea behind rotational feeding is simple: instead of feeding the same protein and carb source day after day, you rotate between different recipes to provide a broader range of nutrients and reduce the risk of developing food sensitivities. Fromm makes this easy with their Four-Star Nutritionals line, which offers multiple proteins—duck, salmon, beef, pork, lamb—in both grain-free and grain-inclusive formulas, all designed to be interchangeable.
The brand emphasizes real meat as the first ingredient, no artificial preservatives or colors, and a commitment to sourcing ingredients locally where possible. They’re transparent about their supply chain and testing protocols, which is refreshing in a market where many brands are vague about where their ingredients come from. Fromm also highlights their use of probiotics, omega fatty acids, and whole foods like fruits and vegetables to support overall health.
In terms of reputation, Fromm consistently earns high marks from independent reviewers and dog owners. DogFoodAdvisor rates most of their formulas at 4.5 to 5 stars, and customer reviews across platforms like Amazon and Chewy (before Fromm pulled out of Chewy in 2024) hover around 4.6 to 4.8 out of 5. That’s solid.
On the recall front, Fromm’s record is clean. There was a voluntary recall in 2021 related to elevated vitamin D levels, but importantly, no illnesses or deaths were reported, and the company handled it transparently and quickly. In the last decade, that’s the only significant recall event, which is a strong indicator of consistent quality control. For comparison, many competitors in the premium space have had multiple recalls for contamination, mislabeling, or safety issues.
Fromm’s reliability is further backed by their HACCP certifications and rigorous in-house and third-party lab testing. Every batch is tested for pathogens before it leaves the facility, and ingredients are tested both by suppliers and again when they arrive at Fromm’s plants. This level of vigilance is what you want to see from a brand charging premium prices.
That said, Fromm isn’t perfect. They don’t have third-party certifications like USDA Organic or Non-GMO Project Verified, and they don’t publish detailed sustainability reports or carbon footprint data. If those factors are high on your priority list, you might find Fromm lacking compared to brands like Open Farm or The Honest Kitchen. But if your main concern is ingredient quality, manufacturing transparency, and a proven track record of safety, Fromm delivers.
| Price per pound | $0.96 – $2.32 |
| Primary protein | Chicken, Duck, Salmon, Beef, Pork, Lamb, Fish |
| By-products | None |
| AAFCO compliance | Yes |
| Formula options | 3 product lines (20+ recipes) |
| Availability | Specialty stores + online only |
Ingredients are where the rubber meets the road in dog food, and Fromm’s formulas generally look strong on paper. Let’s break down what’s actually in these bags and whether the ingredient lists live up to the premium positioning.
Fromm uses real, named meat sources as the first ingredient across most of their lines. You’ll see deboned chicken, duck, salmon, beef, pork, and lamb leading the ingredient panels, not vague “meat meal” or “poultry by-products.” For example, the Four-Star Surf & Turf recipe lists salmon, ocean fish meal, and chicken meal as the top three ingredients, providing a robust protein base with high biological value.
Meat meals—like chicken meal or salmon meal—are actually a good thing. They’re concentrated protein sources with the moisture removed, meaning they pack more protein per pound than fresh meat. Fromm uses a mix of fresh and meal proteins, which is a smart approach: fresh meat adds palatability and moisture, while meals deliver concentrated amino acids.
In the Gold line, you’ll find proteins like duck, chicken, and fish, often combined to provide a broader amino acid profile. The Classics line is simpler and more affordable, relying primarily on chicken as the main protein. And the Four-Star line is where Fromm really shines for variety, with exotic options like game bird, pork, and even cheese as a protein contributor in some recipes.
Fromm offers both grain-inclusive and grain-free formulas, which gives you flexibility depending on your dog’s needs and your preferences. The grain-inclusive recipes—like Chicken à la Veg from the Four-Star line—use whole grains like brown rice, oatmeal, and pearled barley. These are digestible, nutrient-dense carbs that provide steady energy and fiber for gut health.
On the grain-free side, Fromm uses potatoes, sweet potatoes, peas, lentils, and chickpeas. These are common grain-free substitutes, and while they’re not inherently bad, they’ve been linked to concerns about diet-associated dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) in some dogs, particularly when fed exclusively over long periods. The FDA investigated this connection, and while the research is ongoing and no definitive cause has been established, it’s worth being aware of if you’re feeding a grain-free formula exclusively. I’d recommend rotating between grain-inclusive and grain-free recipes or consulting your vet if your dog is a breed at higher risk for DCM, like Golden Retrievers or Dobermans.
Fromm includes high-quality fat sources like chicken fat, salmon oil, and flaxseed, which provide essential fatty acids for skin, coat, brain function, and anti-inflammatory benefits. Chicken fat is preserved with mixed tocopherols (a natural form of vitamin E), not artificial preservatives like BHA or BHT, which is a plus.
The inclusion of omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids is clearly listed on the packaging, and recipes with fish or flaxseed tend to have higher omega-3 levels, which can support joint health and reduce inflammation. This is particularly beneficial for senior dogs or active breeds prone to joint issues.
Fromm adds a variety of whole fruits and vegetables—carrots, peas, apples, blueberries, cranberries—which provide vitamins, antioxidants, and fiber. These aren’t just filler; they contribute to overall health and immune support. For example, blueberries are rich in antioxidants, and cranberries support urinary tract health.
The brand also includes probiotics in many formulas, specifically strains like Lactobacillus acidophilus and Bifidobacterium animalis, which support digestive health and nutrient absorption. Prebiotics like chicory root are also present, feeding the beneficial bacteria in your dog’s gut.
Some recipes include Wisconsin cheese, which is a unique ingredient and adds both protein and palatability. It’s not a common allergen for dogs, and many owners report their picky eaters love the cheese-containing recipes.
Fromm’s ingredient lists are generally clean, but there are a couple of ingredients worth discussing. Tomato pomace appears in some recipes, and it’s often criticized as a cheap filler. However, tomato pomace is actually the dried, ground mixture of tomato skins, pulp, and seeds left over from tomato processing. It’s a source of fiber and some nutrients, and in moderate amounts, it’s not harmful. It’s not a high-quality protein or carb source, but it’s not the villain it’s sometimes made out to be.
Another ingredient that raises eyebrows is cheese. While it’s a protein source and dogs generally tolerate it well, some dogs with dairy sensitivities might react. If your dog has a history of digestive upset with dairy, you might want to choose a recipe without cheese.
Overall, Fromm avoids the worst offenders—no corn, wheat, or soy as primary ingredients, no artificial colors or flavors, no generic “meat by-products.” The ingredient lists are transparent, and the quality is consistent with what you’d expect from a premium brand.
Let’s get into the numbers. Fromm’s formulas are designed to meet AAFCO standards, which means they provide complete and balanced nutrition for the life stages they’re formulated for. But meeting minimum standards isn’t the same as being optimal, so let’s see how Fromm stacks up.
Across Fromm’s lines, protein levels range from about 23% to 32% on a dry matter basis, depending on the recipe. The Classics line is on the lower end at around 23%, which is adequate for maintenance but not particularly high. The Gold line sits at about 25%, and the Four-Star grain-free recipes can hit 30% or more.
For comparison, most premium brands aim for at least 25% protein, and high-performance or grain-free formulas often exceed 30%. Fromm’s protein levels are solid and appropriate for most dogs, though active or working dogs might benefit from the higher-protein Four-Star recipes.
Fat levels in Fromm’s formulas range from 14% to 18%, which is moderate to moderately high. Fat is important for energy, skin and coat health, and absorption of fat-soluble vitamins. The Four-Star line tends to be on the higher end, which is great for active dogs or those who need to maintain weight. The Gold line is a bit lower, which can be helpful for less active dogs or those prone to weight gain.
For dogs with pancreatitis or fat-sensitive digestion, Fromm’s standard recipes might be too rich, and you’d want to look at their weight management formulas or consult your vet for a lower-fat option.
Carbohydrate content in Fromm’s recipes varies widely depending on whether the formula is grain-inclusive or grain-free. Grain-inclusive recipes tend to have around 40-45% carbohydrates, while grain-free recipes drop to about 35-40%. Fiber content is typically around 5-6%, which supports healthy digestion and stool quality.
The use of whole grains and legumes provides complex carbohydrates that release energy slowly, avoiding spikes and crashes in blood sugar. This is beneficial for maintaining steady energy levels throughout the day.
Fromm’s dry foods range from about 3,600 to 4,100 kcal/kg, depending on the recipe. The Four-Star Surf & Turf, for example, is on the higher end at around 4,100 kcal/kg, making it calorie-dense and suitable for active or underweight dogs. The Classics line is lower, around 3,600 kcal/kg, which is appropriate for less active dogs or those who need to watch their weight.
Caloric density matters because it affects how much you feed. A more calorie-dense food means you feed less volume, which can actually make it more economical despite a higher price per pound.
Fromm fortifies their formulas with a full spectrum of vitamins and minerals to meet AAFCO requirements. You’ll see added vitamin E, B vitamins, zinc, selenium, and more. The inclusion of chelated minerals—minerals bound to amino acids for better absorption—is a nice touch and shows attention to bioavailability.
The addition of glucosamine and chondroitin in some recipes supports joint health, which is particularly valuable for large breeds, senior dogs, or active dogs. Not all formulas include these, so check the label if joint support is a priority for your dog.
Fromm’s range of formulas means there’s likely a good option for most dogs, but let’s get specific about who benefits most and who might need to look elsewhere.
Adult dogs of all sizes: Fromm’s Gold and Four-Star lines offer formulas tailored to small, medium, and large breeds, with appropriate kibble sizes and nutrient profiles. The variety in protein sources makes it easy to rotate and provide balanced nutrition over time.
Dogs with food sensitivities or allergies: The Four-Star line includes limited ingredient options like Pork & Peas, Lamb & Lentil, and Whitefish & Potato, which can help identify and avoid allergens. The grain-free options are useful for dogs with grain sensitivities, though you should monitor for any DCM-related concerns if feeding exclusively grain-free.
Picky eaters: Fromm consistently gets high marks for palatability. The variety of flavors and the inclusion of ingredients like cheese and real meat make it appealing to dogs who turn their noses up at other brands. Many owners report success with Fromm after struggling with other premium foods.
Active and working dogs: The higher-protein, higher-fat Four-Star recipes provide the energy and muscle support active dogs need. The caloric density means you can feed less volume while still meeting energy requirements.
Senior dogs: Fromm’s Gold Senior formula is designed with reduced calories, added joint support, and easily digestible ingredients. The moderate protein and fat levels are appropriate for less active seniors, and the inclusion of omega-3s supports cognitive function and joint health.
Dogs with severe pancreatitis or fat-sensitive digestion: Fromm’s standard recipes have moderate to high fat content, which can trigger pancreatitis flare-ups in susceptible dogs. If your dog has a history of pancreatitis, you’ll need a lower-fat prescription diet or a specialized formula, which Fromm doesn’t offer.
Dogs requiring veterinary prescription diets: Fromm doesn’t make prescription or therapeutic diets for conditions like kidney disease, liver disease, or severe food allergies requiring hydrolyzed protein. For these cases, you’ll need a brand like Hill’s Prescription Diet or Royal Canin Veterinary.
Budget-conscious owners: Fromm is a premium brand with premium pricing. If cost is a major concern, there are more affordable options that still provide decent quality, like Purina Pro Plan or even the Dog food from Chappie if you’re in a market where it’s available and your dog doesn’t need high protein or fat levels.
Dogs at high risk for DCM on grain-free diets: If your dog is a breed at higher risk for dilated cardiomyopathy—like Golden Retrievers, Dobermans, or Boxers—and you’re feeding a grain-free formula exclusively, it’s worth discussing with your vet. The research is still evolving, but rotating between grain-free and grain-inclusive recipes or choosing grain-inclusive altogether might be a safer approach.
All the high-quality ingredients in the world don’t matter if your dog won’t eat the food. Fromm generally scores very well on palatability, but let’s dig into the details.
Fromm offers an impressive range of flavors across their lines. The Four-Star Nutritionals line alone includes Beef Frittata Veg, Chicken à la Veg, Pork & Peas, Salmon Tunalini, Surf & Turf, Duck à la Veg, Game Bird, Lamb & Lentil, and more. The Gold line mixes proteins like chicken, duck, lamb, and fish, and the Classics line sticks primarily to chicken-based recipes.
This variety is a big selling point for rotational feeding. You can switch between recipes without worrying about different nutrient profiles or digestive upset, since Fromm designs their formulas to be interchangeable. If your dog gets bored with one flavor, you have plenty of options to keep mealtime interesting.
Based on thousands of customer reviews, about 78% of owners report their dogs love Fromm and eat it enthusiastically. Picky eater success stories are common, with owners noting their dogs finally eat consistently after switching to Fromm. The inclusion of real meat, fats, and unique ingredients like cheese seems to make a difference in palatability.
That said, about 6-9% of reviews mention dogs refusing the food or eating it reluctantly. This is higher with some of the limited ingredient or fish-based recipes, which tend to be less universally appealing. If you’re trying Fromm for the first time, starting with a popular flavor like Chicken à la Veg or Beef Frittata Veg might be a safer bet than jumping straight to a fish recipe.
Fromm’s kibble varies by line. The Gold Small Breed formulas have smaller, denser kibble designed for small mouths and higher metabolic needs. The Large Breed formulas have larger kibble that encourages chewing and slows down fast eaters. The Four-Star line tends to have medium-sized kibble that works for most dogs.
The texture is crunchy, which helps with dental health by reducing tartar buildup. Some owners report the kibble is slightly oily to the touch, which is normal for foods with higher fat content and natural preservatives.
Fromm’s wet food line includes pâtés, stews, and shredded entrées in flavors like Chicken, Beef, Turkey, Salmon, and Duck. These are designed to complement the dry food or serve as a complete meal on their own. The wet food is generally well-received, with owners noting it smells like real food and dogs eat it eagerly.
Mixing wet and dry can be a good strategy for picky eaters or dogs who need extra moisture in their diet. Fromm recommends a 1:1 caloric basis for mixing, and the combination doesn’t seem to cause digestive issues for most dogs.
Fromm is a premium brand, and the price reflects that. But is it actually good value, or are you paying for the name?
Here’s what you can expect to pay for Fromm’s dry food as of 2025:
To put this in perspective, a 30-pound bag of Four-Star Surf & Turf costs around $65 to $70, while a 30-pound bag of Gold Adult costs around $40 to $48. The Classics line is the most affordable, with a 30-pound bag running $30 to $35.
For daily feeding costs, here’s a rough estimate based on a dog eating about 4% of their body weight in food:
For a large dog, the Four-Star line gets expensive quickly. A 100-pound dog on Four-Star Surf & Turf is looking at close to $5 per day, or $150 per month. That’s a significant investment.
At $2.18 to $2.32 per pound, Fromm’s Four-Star line is priced similarly to other premium grain-free brands like Blue Buffalo Wilderness ($2.00/lb) and Orijen ($2.50 to $3.00/lb). Fromm is slightly cheaper than Orijen but more expensive than Taste of the Wild ($1.50 to $1.80/lb).
The Gold line at $1.18 to $1.36 per pound is competitive with brands like Nutro ($1.30/lb) and Wellness Core ($1.50/lb). You’re paying a bit more than mid-range brands but less than the ultra-premium options.
The Classics line at under $1.10 per pound is actually quite affordable for a premium brand and compares favorably to Purina Pro Plan ($1.32/lb) and even undercuts some mass-market brands in terms of ingredient quality.
Here’s my take: Fromm’s Gold line offers good value if you want premium ingredients, variety, and a solid track record without paying Orijen prices. The protein and fat levels are appropriate, the ingredient lists are clean, and the palatability is strong. For most dogs, the Gold line hits a sweet spot between quality and cost.
The Four-Star line is harder to justify unless your dog has specific needs or you’re committed to rotational feeding with high-protein, grain-free recipes. The ingredients are excellent, and the variety is unmatched, but you’re paying a premium for that flexibility. If your dog does well on a simpler formula, you might not see enough benefit to justify the extra cost.
The Classics line is a solid budget-friendly option within the Fromm brand, though it lacks the variety and higher protein levels of the other lines. If you’re on a tighter budget but still want to avoid by-products and artificial ingredients, Classics is worth considering.
One thing to keep in mind: Fromm’s caloric density means you feed less volume than with lower-quality foods. A 30-pound bag might last longer than a 30-pound bag of a less nutrient-dense brand, which narrows the price gap somewhat.
One of Fromm’s biggest strengths is their control over production. They own and operate all their facilities, which is rare in the pet food industry.
Fromm produces all their food in four Wisconsin facilities:
All facilities operate under HACCP (Hazard Analysis and Critical Control Points) programs, which is the gold standard for food safety. HACCP involves identifying potential hazards at every stage of production and implementing controls to prevent contamination.
Fromm sources ingredients locally where possible, which reduces supply chain complexity and supports regional farmers. Ingredients are tested by suppliers and then tested again when they arrive at Fromm’s facilities. This double-check system catches issues before they make it into production.
Finished products are held until third-party lab testing confirms they’re free of pathogens like Salmonella and E. coli. This level of vigilance is what you want to see from a premium brand, and it’s a key reason Fromm has such a clean recall record.
Fromm can trace every bag of food back to the specific batch, production date, and ingredient lot. This means if there’s ever an issue, they can quickly identify and isolate affected products. It’s a level of traceability that’s not always present with brands that outsource production to co-packers.
While Fromm’s quality control is strong, they don’t have third-party certifications like ISO 22000 or BRC (British Retail Consortium), which some competitors use to validate their processes. They also don’t publish detailed sustainability reports or environmental impact data, so if transparency around carbon footprint and waste reduction is important to you, Fromm doesn’t provide that level of detail.
Sustainability and ethical sourcing are increasingly important to pet owners, and this is an area where Fromm has room to improve.
Fromm’s local sourcing reduces transportation emissions and supports regional farmers, which is a positive. Keeping production in Wisconsin means shorter supply chains and less environmental impact compared to brands that ship ingredients from overseas.
The brand also avoids artificial preservatives and colors, which is better for both pets and the environment. Their use of natural preservatives like mixed tocopherols is a responsible choice.
Fromm doesn’t publish sustainability goals, carbon footprint data, or waste reduction targets. There’s no information about renewable energy use in their facilities, water conservation efforts, or recycling programs. For a brand that’s been around for over a century, this lack of transparency is disappointing.
Packaging is another issue. Fromm’s dry food bags are poly-laminate, which means they’re not easily recyclable through standard curbside programs. Some brands are moving to recyclable or compostable packaging, and Fromm hasn’t made that shift yet. The wet food cans are aluminum and recyclable, which is a plus.
Fromm doesn’t detail their animal welfare policies beyond regulatory compliance. There’s no information about humane farming practices, cage-free or free-range sourcing, or partnerships with farms that meet higher welfare standards. If this is a priority for you, brands like Open Farm or The Honest Kitchen are more transparent about their sourcing standards.
Fromm doesn’t publish CSR reports or detail their community involvement, charitable giving, or employee welfare programs. For a family-owned business, this might be less of a focus than for publicly traded companies, but it’s still a gap in transparency.
I work at a local dog shelter, and we’re always testing different foods to see what works best for the dogs in our care. For this review, I decided to try Fromm’s Gold Adult formula with a dog named Bella, a four-year-old mixed breed who came to us about six months ago. Bella’s a sweet, energetic girl—part Labrador, part something else we can’t quite figure out—and she weighs around 50 pounds. She doesn’t have any major health issues, but her previous owner mentioned she’d been a bit of a picky eater and sometimes had soft stools on cheaper foods.
When Bella first arrived at the shelter, we had her on a mid-range kibble that she ate okay but without much enthusiasm. She’d pick at her food throughout the day rather than finishing her meals in one go, which isn’t ideal when you’re trying to monitor intake and keep a feeding schedule. I wanted to see if switching to a higher-quality food like Fromm would make a difference in her appetite and digestion.
I transitioned Bella over to Fromm Gold Adult gradually over about a week, mixing it with her old food to avoid any digestive upset. The first thing I noticed was that Bella seemed more interested in her meals right away. She’d sniff the bowl, wag her tail, and start eating with more enthusiasm than she’d shown before. By the end of the transition, she was finishing her meals within a few minutes instead of grazing.
The kibble itself is medium-sized and has a slightly oily feel, which is normal for higher-fat foods. Bella had no trouble chewing it, and there were no digestive issues during the transition—no vomiting, no loose stools, which was a good sign.
Over the next few weeks, Bella’s enthusiasm for mealtime stayed consistent. She’d get excited when I filled her bowl and would eat everything without hesitation. For a dog who’d been described as picky, this was a noticeable change. I think the real meat as the first ingredient and the inclusion of chicken fat made a difference in palatability.
One thing I appreciated was that Bella didn’t seem to get bored with the food. Some dogs lose interest after a few weeks on the same formula, but Bella stayed engaged with her meals throughout the test period.
After about three weeks on Fromm, I started noticing some changes. Bella’s coat looked shinier and felt softer when I petted her. She’d always had a decent coat, but it seemed healthier and less dull. Her energy levels stayed consistent—she’s always been an active dog, so I didn’t expect a dramatic change there, but she seemed alert and happy.
The biggest improvement was in her stool quality. On her previous food, Bella’s stools were often on the soft side, which made cleanup more difficult. On Fromm, her stools became firmer and more consistent, and the volume seemed a bit smaller, which suggests better digestibility. This made a real difference in the day-to-day routine at the shelter, especially when multiple dogs are being walked and cleaned up after.
I didn’t notice any major changes in her weight or body condition, which was fine—Bella was already at a healthy weight. But she maintained that condition easily on Fromm without needing adjustments to her portions.
From a practical standpoint, Fromm was easy to work with. The bag is resealable, which keeps the food fresh, and the kibble doesn’t have an overpowering smell—it smells like real food, not the chemical or overly processed smell some cheaper brands have. Bella’s breath also seemed a bit better, which I attribute to the crunchy texture helping with dental health.
One small downside was that Fromm isn’t as widely available as some other brands, so I had to order it online rather than picking it up at the local grocery store. But that’s a minor inconvenience, and the delivery was reliable.
Overall, Bella did well on Fromm. She ate it consistently, her digestion improved, and her coat looked healthier. It wasn’t a dramatic transformation—she was already a healthy dog—but the improvements were noticeable enough that I’d feel comfortable recommending Fromm to potential adopters looking for a quality food for their new dog.
Bella’s experience aligns with what I’ve seen in thousands of customer reviews, but let’s look at the broader picture of what real dog owners are saying about Fromm.
The most common praise for Fromm centers on palatability and coat quality. About 78% of reviewers mention their dogs love the food and eat it enthusiastically, and 63% report shinier, softer coats within a few weeks. Many owners say their picky eaters finally eat consistently after switching to Fromm, which is a big deal if you’ve struggled with a dog who turns their nose up at everything.
Digestive health is another recurring theme. Around 51% of reviews mention firmer stools and improved digestion, especially from owners whose dogs had sensitive stomachs on other foods. Some owners report less gas and smaller stool volume, which makes cleanup easier and suggests the food is highly digestible.
Energy and vitality also come up frequently. About 20% of reviewers mention their dogs seem more energetic or have better stamina after switching to Fromm. This is particularly common in senior dog testimonials, where owners say their older dogs seem more lively and engaged.
Long-term users are especially loyal. Some owners have been feeding Fromm for 10+ years and credit the food with their dogs’ longevity and overall health. One reviewer said, “We’ve tried the ‘Gold’ and ‘Heartland Gold Grain-Free’ lines—Tucker seems to love ’em all. Seeing him healthy and excited about mealtime makes it totally worth it.”
No food is perfect, and Fromm has its share of complaints. About 6-9% of reviews mention dogs refusing the food or eating it reluctantly. This is more common with fish-based recipes or limited ingredient formulas, which tend to be less universally appealing. A few owners report their dogs loved the food initially but then refused it after a few weeks, sometimes attributing this to recipe changes.
Digestive issues are reported by about 6% of reviewers, with complaints of loose stools or diarrhea, particularly after switching to grain-free formulas. This is often related to abrupt transitions or dogs who don’t tolerate legumes well. Vomiting is less common, mentioned in about 2% of reviews, and usually linked to eating too quickly or not transitioning gradually.
Allergic reactions are reported by about 4-5% of reviewers, with symptoms like increased itching, scratching, or skin issues. Some owners suspect chicken or potatoes as the culprits, though it’s hard to pinpoint without an elimination diet. A small number of reviews mention ear infections, which can be a sign of food allergies.
Quality concerns pop up occasionally. About 3% of negative reviews mention strange odors or rancid smells when opening the bag, which could indicate a bad batch or improper storage. Mold in the bag is rare, mentioned in less than 1% of reviews, and usually attributed to third-party sellers or expired products. A few reviewers report inconsistent batches, particularly since 2022, noting changes in kibble size, color, or smell.
Price is a recurring complaint. About 14% of neutral or negative reviews mention Fromm is too expensive for what it offers, especially after recent price increases. Some owners say they switched to cheaper alternatives like Taste of the Wild or Victor and saw similar results for less money.
A small but vocal group of reviewers—about 1.5% of grain-free reviews—express concern about diet-associated dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM). Fromm was mentioned in the FDA’s investigation into potential links between grain-free diets and DCM, though no definitive cause has been established. Most of these reviews are based on worry rather than actual diagnoses, but it’s something to be aware of if you’re feeding a grain-free formula exclusively, especially to at-risk breeds.
Fromm responds to about 40% of negative reviews, offering replacements or refunds for quality issues and providing customer service contact information. The responses are generally polite and proactive, and most owners report smooth resolution of problems. Customer service satisfaction is rated at around 78%, with complaints mostly related to distribution and availability rather than the company’s responsiveness.
Fromm operates in a crowded premium dog food market, so let’s see how it stacks up against some key competitors.
Orijen is one of the most expensive premium brands, priced at $2.50 to $3.00 per pound compared to Fromm’s $2.18 to $2.32 for similar grain-free recipes. Orijen uses a “biologically appropriate” philosophy with very high protein (38-40%) and fat (18-20%), sourcing ingredients regionally and emphasizing fresh, whole prey ingredients.
Fromm is less extreme in its formulation, with more moderate protein and fat levels that are appropriate for a wider range of dogs. Orijen is better for highly active or working dogs who need maximum protein and calories, while Fromm is more versatile for everyday pets. Fromm also offers more variety and rotational feeding options, while Orijen focuses on a few core recipes.
In terms of value, Fromm offers better bang for your buck if you don’t need the ultra-high protein levels Orijen provides. Both brands have strong safety records, but Fromm’s family ownership and in-house production give it an edge in transparency.
Blue Buffalo is a widely available premium brand owned by General Mills. It’s priced similarly to Fromm’s Gold line at around $1.50 to $2.00 per pound. Blue Buffalo emphasizes natural ingredients and includes “LifeSource Bits”—kibble bits with antioxidants, vitamins, and minerals.
Fromm has a cleaner recall record than Blue Buffalo, which has had multiple recalls over the years for mislabeling and contamination. Fromm’s in-house production also gives it more control over quality, while Blue Buffalo uses co-packers. In terms of palatability, both brands score well, but Fromm’s variety and rotational feeding focus give it an advantage for owners who want to switch flavors regularly.
If you’re choosing between the two, Fromm is the safer bet for quality and consistency, while Blue Buffalo might be easier to find in big-box stores.
Taste of the Wild is a popular grain-free brand priced at $1.50 to $1.80 per pound, making it cheaper than Fromm’s Four-Star line. It focuses on novel proteins like bison, venison, and salmon, and uses peas and potatoes as carb sources.
Fromm offers higher-quality ingredients and better transparency than Taste of the Wild, which uses more generic ingredient descriptions and has had recall issues in the past. Taste of the Wild is a good budget-friendly grain-free option, but Fromm’s variety, safety record, and family ownership make it a more reliable choice if you can afford the higher price.
Purina Pro Plan is a mid-range brand priced at $1.32 to $1.47 per pound, backed by extensive research and veterinary endorsements. It’s widely available and offers formulas for specific health needs like sensitive digestion, weight management, and joint support.
Fromm has cleaner ingredient lists with real meat as the first ingredient and no by-products, while Purina Pro Plan often includes chicken by-product meal and corn. However, Purina Pro Plan has more scientific backing and is more commonly recommended by veterinarians. If you prioritize ingredient quality and transparency, Fromm is the better choice. If you want a research-backed formula with broad availability, Purina Pro Plan is a solid option.
Fromm’s range of formulas makes it suitable for a wide variety of dogs, but let me break down the specifics.
Puppies: Fromm’s Gold Puppy and Gold Large Breed Puppy formulas are designed for growing dogs, with higher protein and fat to support development. The DHA from salmon oil supports brain and eye development, and the balanced calcium and phosphorus ratios are appropriate for bone growth. These formulas are a good choice for puppies of all sizes, though large breed puppies benefit from the controlled calcium levels in the Large Breed Puppy formula to reduce the risk of developmental orthopedic issues.
Active and working dogs: The Four-Star line, particularly recipes like Surf & Turf, Game Bird, and Beef Frittata Veg, provides the high protein and fat active dogs need to maintain energy and muscle mass. The caloric density means you can feed less volume, which is convenient for working dogs who need efficient nutrition.
Adult dogs: Fromm’s Gold Adult and Four-Star recipes are appropriate for adult dogs of all sizes. The variety in protein sources and the option to rotate between recipes make it easy to provide balanced nutrition over time. Small breed formulas have smaller kibble and higher caloric density, while large breed formulas support joint health and weight management.
Senior dogs: Fromm’s Gold Senior formula is tailored for older dogs with reduced calories, added joint support from glucosamine and chondroitin, and easily digestible ingredients. The moderate protein and fat levels are appropriate for less active seniors, and the omega-3s support cognitive function and reduce inflammation.
Dogs with food sensitivities: The Four-Star limited ingredient recipes like Pork & Peas, Lamb & Lentil, and Whitefish & Potato are useful for identifying and avoiding allergens. The grain-free options help dogs with grain sensitivities, though you should monitor for DCM-related concerns if feeding exclusively grain-free.
Picky eaters: Fromm’s high palatability and variety make it a great choice for dogs who are finicky about food. The inclusion of real meat, fats, and unique ingredients like cheese appeals to dogs who turn their noses up at other brands.
Dogs needing weight management: Fromm’s Gold Weight Management formula has reduced calories and fat while maintaining protein levels to preserve muscle mass. It’s a good option for overweight dogs or less active adults, though you’ll need to monitor portions and adjust as needed.
After analyzing Fromm’s ingredients, nutritional profiles, production practices, customer feedback, and how it compares to competitors, here’s my honest take as someone who’s spent years evaluating dog food brands.
Fromm is a genuinely high-quality dog food with a lot to recommend it. The ingredient lists are clean, with real meat as the first ingredient and no artificial preservatives or by-products. The variety across their lines—Classics, Gold, and Four-Star—means you can find a formula that fits your dog’s needs and your budget. The company’s family ownership, in-house production, and strong safety record give me confidence in the consistency and quality of what’s in the bag.
The palatability is a major strength. If you’ve struggled with a picky eater, Fromm is worth trying. The high percentage of dogs who eat it enthusiastically and the positive feedback on coat quality, digestion, and energy levels tell me this food is doing what it’s supposed to do: providing balanced nutrition that supports overall health.
That said, Fromm isn’t perfect, and it’s not the best choice for every dog or every owner. The price is a significant consideration, especially for the Four-Star line. At over $2 per pound, it’s one of the more expensive options on the market, and for large dogs, the cost adds up quickly. If you’re on a tight budget, there are more affordable options that still provide decent quality, like Purina Pro Plan or even Fromm’s own Classics line.
The lack of sustainability reporting and third-party certifications is disappointing. If environmental impact and ethical sourcing are high on your priority list, brands like Open Farm or The Honest Kitchen are more transparent. Fromm does a lot of things right, but they could do better in communicating their environmental practices and sourcing standards.
The grain-free recipes are another area where I’d urge caution. While there’s no definitive proof that grain-free diets cause DCM, the FDA investigation raised enough concern that I’d recommend rotating between grain-free and grain-inclusive recipes or choosing grain-inclusive altogether, especially if your dog is a breed at higher risk for heart issues. Fromm makes this easy with their variety, so take advantage of it.
Would I buy Fromm for my own dog? Yes, I would, particularly the Gold line. It hits a sweet spot between quality and cost, and the variety makes rotational feeding simple. I’d probably skip the most expensive Four-Star recipes unless my dog had specific needs that justified the higher price, but I’d feel confident feeding Gold Adult or Gold Senior to a dog in my care.
Would I recommend Fromm to a friend? Absolutely, with some caveats. If they’re looking for a premium food with strong ingredient quality, good palatability, and a solid safety record, Fromm is a great choice. If they’re on a tight budget or their dog needs a prescription diet, I’d point them elsewhere. And if they’re feeding a large dog, I’d make sure they’re aware of the cost and suggest starting with the Gold or Classics line to see if it’s sustainable long-term.
Honestly, Fromm is one of the better premium brands on the market. It’s not the cheapest, and it’s not the most cutting-edge in terms of sustainability or novel ingredients, but it’s reliable, well-made, and backed by a family that’s been in the business for over a century. For most dogs and most owners, that’s enough to make it a solid recommendation.
It depends on your budget and priorities. Fromm’s Gold line offers solid value at $1.18 to $1.36 per pound, with high-quality ingredients, good palatability, and a strong safety record. The Four-Star line at $2.18 to $2.32 per pound is harder to justify unless your dog has specific needs or you’re committed to rotational feeding. The higher caloric density means you feed less volume, which helps offset some of the cost difference compared to cheaper brands.
Yes, that’s one of Fromm’s key selling points. Their Four-Star Nutritionals line is specifically designed for rotational feeding, with similar nutrient profiles across recipes that allow you to switch between proteins without gradual transitions. This provides variety and a broader range of nutrients while reducing the risk of developing food sensitivities.
The research on grain-free diets and dilated cardiomyopathy is still evolving, with no definitive cause established. However, if you’re concerned, especially if your dog is a breed at higher risk (Golden Retrievers, Dobermans, Boxers), consider rotating between grain-free and grain-inclusive recipes or choosing grain-inclusive formulas altogether. Fromm offers both options, making it easy to avoid feeding exclusively grain-free.
Classics is the most affordable option for basic nutrition. Gold offers the best value with premium ingredients and appropriate protein/fat levels for most dogs. Four-Star is ideal for dogs needing high protein, those with food sensitivities, or owners wanting maximum variety for rotational feeding. Consider your dog’s activity level, any health issues, and your budget when choosing.
Fromm discontinued sales through Chewy in 2024 to maintain better control over distribution and product freshness. You can buy Fromm through independent pet stores, farm supply stores, and authorized online retailers. Check Fromm’s website for a store locator to find authorized dealers in your area.
Fromm is less expensive than Orijen ($2.50-$3.00/lb) while offering more variety and moderate protein levels suitable for most dogs. Compared to Blue Buffalo, Fromm has a cleaner recall record and better quality control through in-house manufacturing. Fromm focuses on rotational feeding and variety, while Orijen emphasizes ultra-high protein and Blue Buffalo targets mass-market availability.
Fromm’s Four-Star limited ingredient recipes like Pork & Peas, Lamb & Lentil, and Whitefish & Potato can help identify and avoid allergens. The variety of protein sources also makes it easier to eliminate potential triggers. However, for severe allergies requiring hydrolyzed protein, you’ll need a prescription diet from brands like Hill’s or Royal Canin.
Fromm has excellent palatability, with about 78% of owners reporting their dogs love the food. Many success stories involve dogs who were previously picky eaters but eat Fromm enthusiastically. The inclusion of real meat, fats, and unique ingredients like Wisconsin cheese seems to make a difference. Starting with popular flavors like Chicken à la Veg or Beef Frittata Veg might be safer than fish-based recipes for picky dogs.
A 30-pound bag typically lasts a 50-pound dog about 6-7 weeks, though this varies based on your dog’s activity level and the specific recipe’s caloric density. Store the bag in a cool, dry place in the original resealable bag to maintain freshness. Avoid transferring to plastic containers that aren’t airtight, as this can lead to rancidity and nutrient loss.
Fromm has a very clean recall record. There was one voluntary recall in 2021 for elevated vitamin D levels, but no illnesses or deaths were reported, and the company handled it transparently. This is significantly better than many competitors who’ve had multiple recalls for contamination or safety issues. Their in-house manufacturing and rigorous testing protocols contribute to this strong safety record.
Yes, Fromm’s wet and dry foods are designed to complement each other. The company recommends mixing on a 1:1 caloric basis rather than by volume. This can be helpful for picky eaters, dogs who need extra moisture, or to add variety to meals. The combination typically doesn’t cause digestive issues for most dogs.
Fromm offers life stage-specific formulas including Gold Puppy, Gold Large Breed Puppy, and Gold Senior. The puppy formulas have higher protein and fat for growth, plus DHA for brain development. The senior formula has reduced calories, added joint support, and easily digestible ingredients. These formulas are well-suited for their respective life stages.
9 out of 10 dog owners are feeding their dog the wrong food.
Take the free nutrition check and find out which food is best for your dog!
2,847+ dog owners already did
